From 71366e7d457525526f3020aa444481edcc6e7e2d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cristian Cerroni Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2026 17:22:39 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] docs(01): close review and security gates with acceptance pending --- .planning/HANDOFF.json | 34 +++--- .planning/STATE.md | 14 +-- .../.continue-here.md | 4 +- .../01-07-SUMMARY.md | 4 + .../01-FIX-REPORT.md | 114 ++++++++++++++++++ .../01-REVIEW-DISPOSITION.md | 22 ++-- .../01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md | 75 ++++++++++++ .../01-SECURITY.md | 60 +++++++++ .../01-VALIDATION.md | 101 ++++++++++------ .../HANDOFF.md | 2 + docs/compatibility.md | 16 +++ docs/decisions.md | 16 +++ docs/progress.md | 16 +++ docs/tasks.md | 16 +++ 14 files changed, 417 insertions(+), 77 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-FIX-REPORT.md create mode 100644 .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md create mode 100644 .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-SECURITY.md diff --git a/.planning/HANDOFF.json b/.planning/HANDOFF.json index 0613617..8ad591f 100644 --- a/.planning/HANDOFF.json +++ b/.planning/HANDOFF.json @@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ "plan": 7, "task": 3, "total_tasks": 3, - "status": "paused", + "status": "consumed", "completed_tasks": [ { "id": 1, @@ -22,14 +22,16 @@ "status": "partial", "commit": "fc5e936", "actual_acceptance": "0/120 OPEN" + }, + { + "id": 3, + "name": "Full-suite recovery and review integration", + "status": "done", + "commit": "472500b", + "review_fix": "02d182f" } ], "remaining_tasks": [ - { - "id": 3, - "name": "Complete full-suite verification, integration and primary review", - "status": "in_progress" - }, { "id": 2, "name": "Actual original/native combined session and strict acceptance", @@ -38,22 +40,14 @@ ], "blockers": [ { - "description": "Five-hour quota reached15% reserve; user requested pause", - "type": "external" - }, - { - "description": "Original/native/physical/audible evidence and named human reviews pending", - "type": "human_action" + "type": "human_action", + "description": "One combined actual original/native and physical/audible review session remains pending." } ], "async_jobs": [], "background_processes": { - "exec_session_id": 15416, - "active_tests": [], - "log": "artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.log", - "result": "artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json", - "warning": "Result JSON may be old attempt1 until rerun terminates; reconcile timestamps and log.", - "visibility_note": "Sandbox /proc scan found no exact scripts/test.sh argv match; this does not establish completion. Reconcile exec session15416 and result/log timestamps after reset." + "full_suite": "finished exit0,782.049626s", + "result": "artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json" }, "human_actions_pending": [ { @@ -74,6 +68,6 @@ "?? .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md", "?? tools.yaml" ], - "next_action": "After fresh quota recovery, reconcile existing full-suite process/log/result BEFORE rerunning anything; review pending01-07 source and task3 diff, finish verification/integration without skipping on existingSUMMARY.", - "context_notes": "Quota guard triggered at15% and explicitly requested pause. Plans01-05/06 completed, primary reviewed, and pushed throughd18f551. Plan01-07 task1 REDd78b135/GREEN026def9; pending-only task2 projectionfc5e936. These latest01-07 commits await primary source review and are not pushed. Task3 runner/root docs are partial and UNCOMMITTED. Do not rerun completed01-05/06. Do not treat existing01-07SUMMARY orROADMAP text as proof task3/phase finished: task3 full suite and primary review remain unresolved. Preserve untrackedtools.yaml. Fullsuite attempt1 exited1 after556Python checks and27actualNode checks because reporter guard expectedTAP; runner explicitly --test-reporter=tap fix targeted27passed. Current rerun execsession15416 was inGPU/SDL stage atpause:556Python(180fidelity),27Node,23observer,allstandalone managed,mainbuildpassed; final exit not yet verified. artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json may still contain OLD attempt1 exit1 until current supervisor completes: inspect timestamp, log, actualprocess before deciding. Do NOT launch duplicate suite. Current active process metadata retained below. Original/GPU finalchecks remain pending until terminal result. No partial task3 source committed.\nFresh final bundle dist/fidelity/phase01 contains11000 immutable files; materials_ready=true. Exact identities artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json. Strict audit exits1 correctly with0/120accepted,10humanfindingspending,noauditerrors; importedLinuxfailedpreflight anddiagnosticviewer exist. Existingpackage source446930d dirty/diff identities retained. Human tester onlycollects/observes/returnslocally; agent-owned post-return normalizationmapping is incheckpoint-session.md and mustnotinventmissingidentities. NativeWindows/originalDxWnd plusactualLinuxdisplay/physical/audiblereview remainpending. Host hasnoDISPLAY/WAYLAND andonlyauto_nullaudio.\nSequentialexecutorroot /home/cristian/codex/Neutron/GamePort; worktreebasecheckdegradesbecauseorigin/HEADunresolved (actualGitea/main). Modelsinherit; no new dispatch at<=20; pause at<=15. Watcher running and actualautomatic15% steering proven thisturn; noauto-resume. Allgeneratedmedia/packages staylocal. First primaryapprovalreview rejecteddeletionofhistoricalhandoffs, soretain/markconsumedafteruse ratherthandelete. Executor nowinterrupted toendmodelwork; independentauthorizedtest maycontinue. Reconcile tests and partial edits after quotareset, finish task3, primary review all01-07 changes, commit verifiedsource/SUMMARY/tracking, push toGitea, then phaseverification/human_needed ratherthanacceptancepassed." + "next_action": "Finish final phase verification report; then use the prepared combined session checklist and $gsd-verify-work 1 for actual human evidence. Do not repeat completed task3 or advance Phase2 automatically.", + "context_notes": "Quota guard triggered at15% and explicitly requested pause. Plans01-05/06 completed, primary reviewed, and pushed throughd18f551. Plan01-07 task1 REDd78b135/GREEN026def9; pending-only task2 projectionfc5e936. These latest01-07 commits await primary source review and are not pushed. Task3 runner/root docs are partial and UNCOMMITTED. Do not rerun completed01-05/06. Do not treat existing01-07SUMMARY orROADMAP text as proof task3/phase finished: task3 full suite and primary review remain unresolved. Preserve untrackedtools.yaml. Fullsuite attempt1 exited1 after556Python checks and27actualNode checks because reporter guard expectedTAP; runner explicitly --test-reporter=tap fix targeted27passed. Current rerun execsession15416 was inGPU/SDL stage atpause:556Python(180fidelity),27Node,23observer,allstandalone managed,mainbuildpassed; final exit not yet verified. artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json may still contain OLD attempt1 exit1 until current supervisor completes: inspect timestamp, log, actualprocess before deciding. Do NOT launch duplicate suite. Current active process metadata retained below. Original/GPU finalchecks remain pending until terminal result. No partial task3 source committed.\nFresh final bundle dist/fidelity/phase01 contains11000 immutable files; materials_ready=true. Exact identities artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json. Strict audit exits1 correctly with0/120accepted,10humanfindingspending,noauditerrors; importedLinuxfailedpreflight anddiagnosticviewer exist. Existingpackage source446930d dirty/diff identities retained. Human tester onlycollects/observes/returnslocally; agent-owned post-return normalizationmapping is incheckpoint-session.md and mustnotinventmissingidentities. NativeWindows/originalDxWnd plusactualLinuxdisplay/physical/audiblereview remainpending. Host hasnoDISPLAY/WAYLAND andonlyauto_nullaudio.\nSequentialexecutorroot /home/cristian/codex/Neutron/GamePort; worktreebasecheckdegradesbecauseorigin/HEADunresolved (actualGitea/main). Modelsinherit; no new dispatch at<=20; pause at<=15. Watcher running and actualautomatic15% steering proven thisturn; noauto-resume. Allgeneratedmedia/packages staylocal. First primaryapprovalreview rejecteddeletionofhistoricalhandoffs, soretain/markconsumedafteruse ratherthandelete. Executor nowinterrupted toendmodelwork; independentauthorizedtest maycontinue. Reconcile tests and partial edits after quotareset, finish task3, primary review all01-07 changes, commit verifiedsource/SUMMARY/tracking, push toGitea, then phaseverification/human_needed ratherthanacceptancepassed.\nQuota resumed100%; fullsuite recoveredexit0. Task3/SUMMARY/tracking472500b/52a3e2d/215d01e. Review5915128 found5issues, allfixed andindependentlyverified through02d182f,191fidelitypass43.355s,security22/22closed. Currentbundle11001members; exactcurrentidentityreceipt artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json. Humanactualacceptance remains0/120OPEN.\n" } diff --git a/.planning/STATE.md b/.planning/STATE.md index cb491f9..18db741 100644 --- a/.planning/STATE.md +++ b/.planning/STATE.md @@ -3,11 +3,11 @@ gsd_state_version: "1.0" current_phase: 01 current_phase_name: Reproducible Fidelity Baseline status: ready_for_verification -stopped_at: Completed 01-07 autonomous preparation; primary readiness review then one combined human session; acceptance OPEN 0/120 -last_updated: "2026-11-13T21:48:54.245Z" +stopped_at: Phase1 autonomous preparation reviewed; final verification and human acceptance pending +last_updated: "2026-11-13T22:22:35.261Z" last_activity: 2026-11-13 last_activity_desc: 01-07 autonomous preparation verified; actual human acceptance pending 0/120 -state_head: 52a3e2d5ff19a87e1bd268cdda8eb0ec6bf5e451 +state_head: 02d182f35de643f9d68699b2fff1d219dd132edb progress: total_phases: 8 completed_phases: 0 @@ -29,7 +29,7 @@ See: .planning/PROJECT.md (updated 2026-11-12) Phase: 01 (Reproducible Fidelity Baseline) — HUMAN ACCEPTANCE PENDING Plan: 7 of 7 -Status: Ready for primary review — 7/7 autonomous preparation records; actual 01-07-02 capture/review human_needed, 0/120 accepted. Phase 1 remains open; Phase 2 not advanced. +Status: Preparation complete; actual original/native acceptance human_needed Last activity: 2026-11-13 — Task 3 committed, complete local suite passed in 782.05s; final summary committed. Progress: [░░░░░░░░░░] 0% @@ -108,6 +108,6 @@ No original-required category deferred outside full reconstruction. Later phases ## Session Continuity -Last session: 2026-11-13T21:48:54.215Z -Stopped at: Completed 01-07 autonomous preparation; primary readiness review then one combined human session; acceptance OPEN 0/120 -Resume file: None +Last session: 2026-11-13T22:22:35.231Z +Stopped at: Phase1 autonomous preparation reviewed; final verification and human acceptance pending +Resume file: docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/.continue-here.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/.continue-here.md index 39e779d..fbbe08e 100644 --- a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/.continue-here.md +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/.continue-here.md @@ -1,10 +1,12 @@ + + --- context: phase phase: 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline plan: "07" task: 3 total_tasks: 3 -status: paused +status: consumed last_updated: "2026-11-13T17:28:45.982275+00:00" --- diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-07-SUMMARY.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-07-SUMMARY.md index 85ae7fd..9d2e7e6 100644 --- a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-07-SUMMARY.md +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-07-SUMMARY.md @@ -190,3 +190,7 @@ All created source/test/checklist/baseline files, final local checkpoint, comple suite receipt and exact identity receipt exist. All five recorded commits are ancestors of the measured HEAD. Final readiness passes and strict audit retains errors=[], 0/120 and ten pending findings. Unrelated `tools.yaml` is preserved. + +## Independent review closure + +Five confirmed findings were fixed and independently verified; see01-REVIEW.md,01-FIX-REPORT.md,01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md and01-REVIEW-DISPOSITION.md. Final refinement02d182f requires actual artifact bytes at the scenario boundary;191 fidelity checks pass43.355s. The new checkpoint has11,001 immutable entries with current local identities in artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json; prior identity notes remain historical. All22 planned security threats are closed, while actual0/120 acceptance and ten named human findings stayOPEN. No original/native acceptance or phase advancement is implied. diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-FIX-REPORT.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-FIX-REPORT.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9bbc97c --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-FIX-REPORT.md @@ -0,0 +1,114 @@ +--- +phase: 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline +fixed_at: 2026-11-13T22:09:37Z +review_path: .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW.md +iteration: 1 +findings_in_scope: 5 +fixed: 5 +skipped: 0 +status: all_fixed +--- + +# Phase 01: Code Review Fix Report + +All five confirmed findings were fixed. Their logic changes require independent +human/reviewer verification; automated results below establish the stated tooling +contracts, never original/native gameplay acceptance. No runtime/gameplay source, +original file, package bytes, review disposition, or phase state was changed. + +| Finding | Status | Commit | Applied fix and regression | +|---|---|---|---| +| CR-01 | fixed: requires human verification | `5569bc2` | Carry the actual selected receipt path into digest review. Two different sibling JSON files without a sidecar prove that only the selected file's digest satisfies the human finding; absent/unrelated digests leave findings pending. | +| CR-02 | fixed: requires human verification | `bda35e5` | Supply the complete checkpoint original file inventory, recompute its digest, and bind `identity.executable.original_member` plus size/header/hash to the exact pristine member. Original pre/post/package/resources require full baseline file records and digest. Positive original fixtures retain actual member/executable hashes; wrong executable/member and altered inventory records fail. Writable-copy post changes are separately identified and remain allowed. | +| CR-03 | fixed: requires human verification | `6e5ee0b` | Bind both lifetimes to the validated named `identity.copy_pre` record; retained lifetimes also require `identity.retained_copy`. Unknown hashes and hashes of launcher/package/other state records fail. Fixtures now retain distinct actual copy-state files. | +| WR-01 | fixed: requires human verification | `548c97a` | Assemble the existing validated ledger projection before review export, seal it at `protocol/capability-ledger.json`, and compare viewer current/history against it during readiness. Actual preparation-to-bundled-renderer regression retains the named current and superseded startup records; a sealed viewer missing history is rejected. | +| WR-02 | fixed: requires human verification | `2608517` | Recover missing `run.json` only as aborted from the retained incomplete record. Preserve the raw initial bytes as an importable `recovery-initial.json` diagnostic artifact, retain session/start identity, remove initial placeholder end clocks, and reject captured promotion or launch-aligned events. Shared validation/import permits this open aborted record with absent end clocks. | + +WR-01 has one additional positive regression commit, `a821754`, proving readiness +on a standalone copied checkpoint with no source Git checkout. No fix was skipped +or rolled back. Five finding commits plus this verification commit were made. + +Modified source: `tools/recon/fidelity_acceptance.py`, `fidelity_receipts.py`, +`fidelity_checkpoint.py`, and `scripts/collect-fidelity-windows.ps1`. Tests: +`tests/test_fidelity_acceptance.py`, `test_fidelity_scenarios.py`, +`test_fidelity_checkpoint.py`, and `fidelity-windows.Tests.ps1`. Field contracts: +`docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md` and `windows-session.md`. No new source file +or dependency was required. + +## Verification + +All gates ran locally in the **main checkout**. The primary explicitly authorized +a temporary `workflow.use_worktrees=false` override. Its original absent setting +was restored without staging or committing it; the unused clean worktree was +removed before edits. Unrelated untracked `tools.yaml` remains unchanged. Normal +Git hooks ran for every commit. The WR-01 refinement was folded into its commit +before the primary's no-rebase steering arrived; subsequent history is preserved. + +Logs are retained under ignored `artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/`: + +- `python-fidelity.log`: all 189 fidelity regressions passed in 40.072 seconds. + Initial sandbox execution hit eight loopback-socket permission errors; the + successful scoped-escalation run permits only the local tests' necessary host + operations. These were environment errors, not accepted failed tests. +- `acceptance-final.log`: 29 acceptance tests passed after the final standalone + transfer regression was added. This includes the refined readiness path; these + tests overlap the 189-test run and are not added to its count. +- `node-viewer-direct.log`: 27 actual Node behavior tests passed. On this host + `node --test` reports an aggregate one-file result; direct execution supplied + the explicit 27-test count. The preparation test also rendered the real bundled + model with the bundled renderer and a DOM double, without claiming browser + playback evidence. +- `powershell.log`: 18 package-free synthetic tooling checks passed under cached + Linux-hosted PowerShell. This is not native Windows execution evidence. +- `recovered-import.log`: the actual incomplete-only PowerShell output passed + shared validation and atomic import; accepted is false. Raw fixture output and + imported bytes are retained in separate `test-windows-results/` and + `test-recovered-imports/` namespaces. +- `original-preservation.log`: all 539 original files unchanged. The same + inventory command passed after assembly as well; preparation independently + checked the original inventory before and after copying. +- Python parse checks and `git diff --check` passed. The prior 13-minute full + managed/GPU suite was not repeated because these changes touch tooling and + evidence contracts only. + +## Fresh immutable checkpoint + +The final checkpoint was assembled **once**, using unchanged existing +`artifacts/fidelity/01-05-packages/{linux-x64,win-x64}` bytes. The prior tree was +preserved at `dist/fidelity/phase01-pre-review-48100025`; the documented current +path remains `dist/fidelity/phase01`. No sealed member was patched after assembly. +Mutable results contain a fresh import of the existing failed Linux preflight +receipt and the unchanged pending human-review controls; no captured evidence was +invented. The former assembly remains historical evidence. + +| Item | Identity/result | +|---|---| +| Current checkpoint | `dist/fidelity/phase01` | +| Immutable members | 11001 | +| READY SHA-256 | `7ceebcb3a22549a59bb9f7032c5c686b4ca4d32cf7b6a7d934e12e37f05e7aba` | +| Manifest SHA-256 | `a4da759bb264d63b716a931ae3b16a410baf01e36a7b2696ae8ed5649f77f7a9` | +| Tool commit | `a821754b6755151a0e33e4ac5065c8efd252b2e6` | +| Tool working-tree provenance | Tracked diff empty; dirty true solely from preserved untracked `tools.yaml`, identified by the manifest | +| Sealed runtime source | `446930d2a30d6d616c60ac5e59e4169a840bea09`, dirty true | +| Runtime publish diff | `90cef95669caece53fe2d2c4736cf2ac05ed27f5d25ca03ab572589686bcb73d` | +| Linux package tree | `124cf271e4952f3822eec5c24358447fcffc9e9e1803aded8d96d4d4472dc5a3` | +| Windows package tree | `335e5b75ec15c0fa904113d8b69d4f50e2cfa403f1f2f225353bd9e586322ef4` | +| Startup viewer projection | Two current and two historical records retained | +| Readiness | Exit 0, `materials_ready: true`, `acceptance: human_needed` | +| Strict acceptance | Exit 1, 0/120, no structural errors, all ten human findings pending | + +`prepare-checkpoint.log`, `readiness.json`, `acceptance.json`, and +`failed-linux-import.json` retain the actual results. The readiness and acceptance +reports also reside under the current bundle's mutable `results/` directory. +The ten pending findings remain A1, A2, EVID-02-unclassified, +EVID-04-unclassified, P1, P2, P3, browser, paired_review, and physical_input. +The host still lacks actual original/native Windows capture access and a usable +Linux display/audio session. Independent re-review and the primary's remaining +security/coverage gates precede any combined capture request. + +This report is intentionally uncommitted for the primary workflow to review and +commit. No push, package upload, original execution, or original write occurred. + +## Final artifact-boundary refinement + +CR-03 independent re-review caught pathless hash-only named records. RED48fca0d reproduces fresh/retained missing-file, wrong-size and hash-only cases; GREEN02d182f validates actual named files inside scenario observation with an explicit root. All191 fidelity tests pass in43.355s; focused26 scenario/23 capture/29 acceptance checks pass. Independent reviewer confirms allfive findings fixed; security auditor closes22/22 planned threats. The earlier11001-file bundle is retained locally; current dist/fidelity/phase01 is freshly assembled from corrected source with original runtime package identities unchanged. diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW-DISPOSITION.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW-DISPOSITION.md index a69bb41..42b9740 100644 --- a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW-DISPOSITION.md +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW-DISPOSITION.md @@ -5,25 +5,25 @@ titles: json findings: - id: CR-01 severity: critical - disposition: open + disposition: fixed title: "Human review is checked against a different file from the selected receipt" - id: CR-02 severity: critical - disposition: open + disposition: fixed title: "Original applicability never binds the executed executable or preservation inventories" - id: CR-03 severity: critical - disposition: open + disposition: fixed title: "Fresh-copy continuity accepts a hash that identifies no artifact" - id: WR-01 severity: warning - disposition: open + disposition: fixed title: "Checkpoint assembly bypasses the capability ledger projection" - id: WR-02 severity: warning - disposition: open + disposition: fixed title: "An interrupted Windows collector cannot be finalized through the documented recovery command" -open: 5 +open: 0 total: 5 recorded: 2026-11-13T21:58:50.502559+00:00 --- @@ -32,8 +32,8 @@ recorded: 2026-11-13T21:58:50.502559+00:00 | Finding | Severity | Disposition | Source | |---|---|---|---| -| CR-01 | critical | open | Reproduced; fix in progress | -| CR-02 | critical | open | Reproduced; fix in progress | -| CR-03 | critical | open | Reproduced; fix in progress | -| WR-01 | warning | open | Reproduced; fix in progress | -| WR-02 | warning | open | Reproduced; fix in progress | +| CR-01 | critical | fixed | 01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md; independent re-review | +| CR-02 | critical | fixed | 01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md; independent re-review | +| CR-03 | critical | fixed | 01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md; independent re-review | +| WR-01 | warning | fixed | 01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md; independent re-review | +| WR-02 | warning | fixed | 01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md; independent re-review | diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..955db88 --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +--- +phase: 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline +verified: 2026-11-13T22:19:18Z +review_path: .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW.md +fix_report_path: .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-FIX-REPORT.md +verified_head: 02d182f35de643f9d68699b2fff1d219dd132edb +findings_verified: 5 +fixed: 5 +open: 0 +findings: + critical: 0 + warning: 0 + info: 0 + total: 0 +status: clean +--- + +# Phase 01 review-fix verification + +All five fixes are verified. The final CR-03 refinement requires actual backing artifacts for named copy-state identities and rejects the hash-only records that survived its first fix. No reviewed finding remains open. + +| Finding | Disposition | Independent verification | +|---|---|---| +| CR-01 | FIXED | The selected path is retained and its own digest is compared with the human finding. The sibling-digest and absent-digest regressions leave human checks pending; the actual selected-file digest satisfies that boundary. | +| CR-02 | FIXED | Complete baseline records and their recomputed digest bind original pre/post/package/resources. The explicit executed `original_member` binds executable size/header/hash. Wrong executable/member and inconsistent inventories are rejected; independently identified writable `copy_post` changes remain allowed. | +| CR-03 | FIXED | Scenario validation now checks the actual named copy-pre artifact for both lifetimes and the retained snapshot for retained runs. Previous hash-only reproductions and an isolated retained-snapshot reproduction are rejected; valid named state files still qualify. | +| WR-01 | FIXED | Assembly exports the validated ledger projection; readiness compares current/history with the sealed projection. The preparation-to-bundled-renderer check preserves named current/superseded records. The standalone-transfer check needs no source Git checkout, and missing viewer history is rejected. | +| WR-02 | FIXED | A real Linux-hosted PowerShell finalizer reproduction recovered an incomplete-only synthetic run as aborted. Initial raw bytes and session identity survived, end clocks remained absent, captured promotion was rejected, and shared validation plus atomic import succeeded with acceptance false. | + +## CR-03 refinement verified + +**Original classification:** BLOCKER +**Current disposition:** FIXED by `02d182f35de643f9d68699b2fff1d219dd132edb`, with regression `48fca0d`. +**File:** `/home/cristian/codex/Neutron/GamePort/tools/recon/fidelity_receipts.py:667-678` +**Related:** `/home/cristian/codex/Neutron/GamePort/tools/recon/fidelity_receipts.py:383-385` + +At `a821754`, `_scenario_observation()` compared continuity digests with named identity strings while the generic validator skipped dictionaries without `path`. The refinement now passes the receipt root to scenario validation and calls `_checked_artifact()` on the actual named state records before comparing digests. The scenario audit and Linux capture matrix both pass their artifact root; their direct test callers were updated as well. + +The bounded reproduction below uses existing synthetic metadata fixtures and launches no game. It previously demonstrated the gap and now demonstrates rejection for both native lifetimes: + +```python +from test_fidelity_scenarios import FidelityScenarios +import fidelity_receipts as receipts + +fixture = FidelityScenarios() +fixture.setUp() +try: + for lifetime in ('fresh', 'retained'): + value, root = fixture.receipt( + lifetime + '-natural-ordinary', 'dialogue-return') + value['identity']['copy_pre'] = {'sha256': 'f' * 64} + value['continuity']['copy_pre_sha256'] = 'f' * 64 + if lifetime == 'retained': + value['identity']['retained_copy'] = {'sha256': 'e' * 64} + value['continuity']['retained_copy_sha256'] = 'e' * 64 + result = receipts.audit_scenarios( + fixture.protocol(), [(value, root)]) + print(lifetime, result['accepted'], result['invalid']) +finally: + fixture.doCleanups() +``` + +Run from the repository with `PYTHONPATH=tests:tools/recon`. Earlier output at `a821754` was `fresh 1 []` and `retained 1 []`. Rerunning at `02d182f` gives zero accepted slots and `Reference must be a bounded relative POSIX path` in each invalid list. A third reproduction retaining valid copy-pre but supplying only a hash for `identity.retained_copy` is rejected independently. The unmodified fresh and retained metadata controls each still accept one slot. + +**Additional verification:** Four selected scenario tests passed in **0.424 seconds**: backing-file rejection for both lifetimes, named continuity binding, unrelated retained-snapshot rejection, and complete positive coverage of all 120 metadata slots. The new backing-file test covers hash-only, missing-file and wrong-size state identities, including the retained snapshot. This closes the reported artifact-binding gap without changing the four other verified fixes. + +## Verification evidence and limits + +Read the historical review, fix report and actual source/test diffs for `5569bc2`, `bda35e5`, `6e5ee0b`, `548c97a`, `2608517`, and `a821754`, then the final `48fca0d` regression and `02d182f` refinement. Initially ran 11 selected Python tests in **2.109 seconds**, all passing: selected-file review binding; original executable/member and inventory rejection; mutable generated-copy allowance; complete positive metadata matrix; standalone readiness without Git; malformed viewer history; actual assembled model through its bundled renderer; named pre/retained continuity; and aborted missing-end-clock import. The additional hash-only identity gap discovered during that verification is closed by the independently repeated checks above. + +Separately exercised the actual PowerShell recovery function with a disposable synthetic prepared checkpoint, rejected captured promotion, recovered raw media, compared both raw initial copies byte-for-byte, verified absent end clocks, validated and imported the resulting open aborted receipt. This was Linux-hosted tooling execution, not native Windows evidence. + +No full suite, whole 11,001-file checkpoint readiness/hash walk, original execution or gameplay capture was repeated. The primary's current bundle identities and pending 0/120 human acceptance remain separate evidence; this verification does not promote them. Source and tests were read-only, no commit was made, and unrelated concurrent report edits were preserved. + +Historical `01-REVIEW.md` is unchanged; its SHA-256 is `493c0b9b7b491f7dcc896d6cfda675ced837f56ee32daf2bbf1cd98f1527f74c`. diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-SECURITY.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-SECURITY.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6f5f735 --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-SECURITY.md @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +--- +phase: "01" +slug: reproducible-fidelity-baseline +status: verified +threats_open: 0 +threats_total: 22 +threats_closed: 22 +asvs_level: 1 +block_on: high +register_authored_at_plan_time: true +verified_head: 02d182f35de643f9d68699b2fff1d219dd132edb +created: "2026-11-13T22:21:09.119266+00:00" +--- + +# Phase 01 — Security + +The typed security auditor verified all planned mitigation boundaries. The repeated reserved T-01-SC is counted once. All dispositions are mitigate; no accepted or transferred risks. + +## Trust Boundaries + +Originals → generated copies; local paths → file/process operations; media/receipts → review and acceptance; observer → gameplay; transferred checkpoint → immutable validation. + +## Threat Register + +| Threat ID | Category | Severity | Disposition | Mitigation evidence | Status | +|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| T-01-01 | Tampering | high | mitigate | fidelity_receipts.py:123,221,239,257 | closed | +| T-01-02 | Spoofing | high | mitigate | fidelity_receipts.py:275,667,672,714 | closed | +| T-01-03 | Tampering | high | mitigate | fidelity_receipts.py:198,212,482,500 | closed | +| T-01-04 | Information disclosure | high | mitigate | fidelity_review.py:202,211,219,274 | closed | +| T-01-05 | Tampering | high | mitigate | viewer.mjs:2,190; fidelity_review.py:238 | closed | +| T-01-06 | Spoofing | medium | mitigate | viewer.mjs:43,79,302,318,324 | closed | +| T-01-07 | Spoofing | high | mitigate | fidelity_ledger.py:97,197,203,285 | closed | +| T-01-08 | Repudiation | medium | mitigate | fidelity_ledger.py:69,220,299,320 | closed | +| T-01-09 | Tampering | medium | mitigate | fidelity_ledger.py:117,339,372 | closed | +| T-01-10 | Tampering | high | mitigate | FidelityObservation.cs:54,78,93,109; test_fidelity_observation.py:130 | closed | +| T-01-11 | Denial of service | medium | mitigate | FidelityObservation.cs:165,171,179,192,233 | closed | +| T-01-12 | Spoofing | high | mitigate | FidelityObservation.cs:47,109,130,166; Program.cs:18,1328 | closed | +| T-01-13 | Elevation of privilege | high | mitigate | collect-fidelity-windows.ps1:128,136,144,253,303 | closed | +| T-01-14 | Tampering | high | mitigate | fidelity_checkpoint.py:103,120,198,215,220 | closed | +| T-01-15 | Spoofing | high | mitigate | collect-fidelity-windows.ps1:176,208,234,285,332 | closed | +| T-01-16 | Tampering | high | mitigate | fidelity_capture.py:154,156,195,239,347 | closed | +| T-01-17 | Spoofing | high | mitigate | fidelity_capture.py:85,98,107,325,338 | closed | +| T-01-18 | Denial of service | medium | mitigate | fidelity_capture.py:30,128,148,202,220,224 | closed | +| T-01-19 | Spoofing | high | mitigate | fidelity_acceptance.py:124; fidelity_receipts.py:275,667,672,714; fidelity_capture.py:390 | closed | +| T-01-20 | Tampering | high | mitigate | fidelity_receipts.py:453,482,488,494,500 | closed | +| T-01-21 | Repudiation | medium | mitigate | fidelity_acceptance.py:127,130,160,184; fidelity_ledger.py:328 | closed | +| T-01-SC | Tampering | high | mitigate | fidelity_checkpoint.py:301; collect-fidelity-windows.ps1:253; observer csproj:1 | closed | + +## Accepted Risks Log + +No accepted risks. + +## Security Audit Trail + +Initial source audit identified 20/22 closed and T-01-02/T-01-19 open because hash-only copy identities bypassed file checks. Regression48fca0d reproduced it; fix02d182f validates actual named artifacts at the scenario boundary. Independent auditor reinspection closes both. Code re-review confirms all five findings fixed; see01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md. All191 affected fidelity regressions pass in43.355s. + +## Sign-Off + +All22 planned threats have implemented, verified mitigations; threats_open=0. This tooling verdict does not approve original/native gameplay, physical input, audio or human findings; runtime acceptance remains0/120 OPEN. diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-VALIDATION.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-VALIDATION.md index bda1d8c..1decaf5 100644 --- a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-VALIDATION.md +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-VALIDATION.md @@ -1,9 +1,9 @@ --- phase: "01" slug: "reproducible-fidelity-baseline" -status: draft -nyquist_compliant: false -wave_0_complete: false +status: validated +nyquist_compliant: true +wave_0_complete: true created: "2026-11-12" --- @@ -13,12 +13,12 @@ created: "2026-11-12" | Property | Value | |---|---| -| Framework | Existing Python stdlib unittest, standalone .NET 10 console projects; proposed Node built-in tests for pure viewer logic | +| Framework | Existing Python stdlib unittest, standalone .NET 10 console projects; Node built-in tests for pure viewer logic | | Config file | Existing scripts/test.sh and scripts/env.sh; no new package dependencies | -| Quick run command | `python3 -m unittest discover -s tests -p 'test_fidelity_*.py' -v` (new tests created with their owning slice) | -| Viewer quick command | `node --test tests/fidelity-viewer.test.mjs` (new test file created with viewer slice) | -| Full suite command | `scripts/test.sh` plus the viewer quick command | -| Runtime | Quick target below 30 seconds; measure during execution. Full GPU/original-data suite runs at wave boundaries and has a separate measured duration. | +| Quick run command | `python3 -m unittest discover -s tests -p 'test_fidelity_*.py' -v` | +| Viewer quick command | `node --test tests/fidelity-viewer.test.mjs` | +| Full suite command | `scripts/test.sh` (includes counted Python, Node viewer and managed observer checks) | +| Runtime | Broad fidelity run: 40.072 seconds (30-second target exceeded); focused tooling checks typically 1–5 seconds, process/observer checks can take longer. Complete local suite: 782.049626 seconds. | ## Sampling Rate @@ -30,35 +30,35 @@ created: "2026-11-12" ## Per-Task Verification Map -Final task bindings below reference the exact executable `` blocks in the named PLAN.md/task. Each block carries its adjacent observable ``; Python commands assert the minimum discovered count before running. These tests are intended new artifacts, not checks already executed. +Final task bindings below reference the exact executable `` blocks in the named PLAN.md/task. Each block carries its adjacent observable ``; Python commands assert the minimum discovered count before running. The tests exist and have run with positive counts. The status column separates passing automation from actual capture/review still OPEN. Shared EVID requirement acceptance is not implied by any green tooling row. -| Task | Wave | Exact automated command binding | Minimum count / threat refs | -|---|---|---|---| -| 01-01-01 | 1 | 01-01-PLAN.md task 01-01-01: counted `test_fidelity_sessions.py` runner and mandated original inventory invocation | 16; T-01-01/02/03 | -| 01-01-02 | 1 | 01-01-PLAN.md task 01-01-02: counted `test_fidelity_scenarios.py` runner | 12; T-01-02 | -| 01-02-01 | 2 | 01-02-PLAN.md task 01-02-01: counted `test_fidelity_review.py` runner; `node --test tests/fidelity-viewer.test.mjs` | Python 10, Node positive; T-01-04/05/06 | -| 01-02-02 | 2 | 01-02-PLAN.md task 01-02-02: `node --test tests/fidelity-viewer.test.mjs` | 16; T-01-04/05/06 | -| 01-03-01 | 2 | 01-03-PLAN.md task 01-03-01: counted `test_fidelity_ledger.py` runner | 12; T-01-07/08/09 | -| 01-03-02 | 2 | 01-03-PLAN.md task 01-03-02: counted ledger runner; `python3 tools/recon/fidelity_ledger.py validate --ledger docs/evidence/capabilities.json --requirements .planning/REQUIREMENTS.md` | 16 tests, 33 requirements; T-01-07/08/09 | -| 01-04-01 | 2 | 01-04-PLAN.md task 01-04-01: exact sourced-SDK observer command and counted `test_fidelity_observation.py` runner | Managed 8, Python 4; T-01-10/11/12 | -| 01-04-02 | 2 | 01-04-PLAN.md task 01-04-02: sourced-SDK observer/build and MovementTests/DirectorTests/CheckpointTests/BodyOwnershipTests commands | Managed 14 plus positive existing groups; T-01-10/11/12 | -| 01-05-01 | 3 | 01-05-PLAN.md task 01-05-01: counted `test_fidelity_checkpoint.py` runner; `bash -n scripts/prepare-fidelity-checkpoint.sh` | 12; T-01-13/14/15 | -| 01-05-02 | 3 | 01-05-PLAN.md task 01-05-02: counted checkpoint runner; package-free PowerShell command deferred to final human session | Python 16, Windows 8; T-01-13/14/15 | -| 01-06-01 | 4 | 01-06-PLAN.md task 01-06-01: counted `test_fidelity_capture.py` runner | 10; T-01-16/17/18 | -| 01-06-02 | 4 | 01-06-PLAN.md task 01-06-02: counted capture runner and original inventory command | 14; T-01-16/17/18 | -| 01-07-01 | 5 | 01-07-PLAN.md task 01-07-01: counted `test_fidelity_acceptance.py` runner; `python3 tools/recon/fidelity_acceptance.py ready --checkpoint dist/fidelity/phase01` | 14; T-01-19/20/21 | -| 01-07-02 | 5 | `python3 tools/recon/fidelity_acceptance.py audit --checkpoint dist/fidelity/phase01 --results dist/fidelity/phase01/results --require-complete` | Real matrix/native/original/human checks required; T-01-19/20/21 | -| 01-07-03 | 5 | `scripts/test.sh`; `python3 tools/recon/inventory.py ../Original --verify docs/original-manifest.json` | Positive consolidated counts, 539 originals; all threats | +| Task | Wave | Exact automated command binding | Minimum count / threat refs | Actual result | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| 01-01-01 | 1 | 01-01-PLAN.md task 01-01-01: counted `test_fidelity_sessions.py` runner and mandated original inventory invocation | 16; T-01-01/02/03 | green: 29 session tests; 539 originals | +| 01-01-02 | 1 | 01-01-PLAN.md task 01-01-02: counted `test_fidelity_scenarios.py` runner | 12; T-01-02 | green: 25 scenario tests | +| 01-02-01 | 2 | 01-02-PLAN.md task 01-02-01: counted `test_fidelity_review.py` runner; `node --test tests/fidelity-viewer.test.mjs` | Python 10, Node positive; T-01-04/05/06 | green: 21 review + 27 Node tests | +| 01-02-02 | 2 | 01-02-PLAN.md task 01-02-02: `node --test tests/fidelity-viewer.test.mjs` | 16; T-01-04/05/06 | green: 27 Node tests | +| 01-03-01 | 2 | 01-03-PLAN.md task 01-03-01: counted `test_fidelity_ledger.py` runner | 12; T-01-07/08/09 | green: 31 ledger tests | +| 01-03-02 | 2 | 01-03-PLAN.md task 01-03-02: counted ledger runner; `python3 tools/recon/fidelity_ledger.py validate --ledger docs/evidence/capabilities.json --requirements .planning/REQUIREMENTS.md` | 16 tests, 33 requirements; T-01-07/08/09 | green: 31 tests; 33 requirement mappings validated | +| 01-04-01 | 2 | 01-04-PLAN.md task 01-04-01: exact sourced-SDK observer command and counted `test_fidelity_observation.py` runner | Managed 8, Python 4; T-01-10/11/12 | green: 23 managed + 7 process tests | +| 01-04-02 | 2 | 01-04-PLAN.md task 01-04-02: sourced-SDK observer/build and MovementTests/DirectorTests/CheckpointTests/BodyOwnershipTests commands | Managed 14 plus positive existing groups; T-01-10/11/12 | green: observer/build and protected groups 28/23/4/3 | +| 01-05-01 | 3 | 01-05-PLAN.md task 01-05-01: counted `test_fidelity_checkpoint.py` runner; `bash -n scripts/prepare-fidelity-checkpoint.sh` | 12; T-01-13/14/15 | green: 25 checkpoint tests; shell syntax | +| 01-05-02 | 3 | 01-05-PLAN.md task 01-05-02: counted checkpoint runner; package-free PowerShell command deferred to final human session | Python 16, Windows 8; T-01-13/14/15 | green: 25 Python + 18 Linux-hosted PowerShell checks; native Windows session OPEN | +| 01-06-01 | 4 | 01-06-PLAN.md task 01-06-01: counted `test_fidelity_capture.py` runner | 10; T-01-16/17/18 | green: 23 capture tests; actual Linux capture OPEN | +| 01-06-02 | 4 | 01-06-PLAN.md task 01-06-02: counted capture runner and original inventory command | 14; T-01-16/17/18 | green: 23 capture tests; 539 originals; actual matrix OPEN | +| 01-07-01 | 5 | 01-07-PLAN.md task 01-07-01: counted `test_fidelity_acceptance.py` runner; `python3 tools/recon/fidelity_acceptance.py ready --checkpoint dist/fidelity/phase01` | 14; T-01-19/20/21 | green: 29 acceptance tests; readiness exit 0 | +| 01-07-02 | 5 | `python3 tools/recon/fidelity_acceptance.py audit --checkpoint dist/fidelity/phase01 --results dist/fidelity/phase01/results --require-complete` | Real matrix/native/original/human checks required; T-01-19/20/21 | OPEN: strict audit exit 1, errors=[], 0/120; fail-closed behavior covered by passing acceptance tests | +| 01-07-03 | 5 | `scripts/test.sh`; `python3 tools/recon/inventory.py ../Original --verify docs/original-manifest.json` | Positive consolidated counts, 539 originals; all threats | green: completed full suite exit 0; 539 originals | -All plan subcommands/paths are explicitly introduced in their owning tasks before verification. Run every focused task command after that task; at integrated checkpoint run the full suite once and repeat only after changes/failures. Quick checks target below 30 seconds, to be measured. Existing full suite and native runs can take longer and record separate durations. No new runtime/fixture/Windows results are claimed here. +All 15 task bindings were checked against the seven PLAN verify blocks and SUMMARY interfaces. No missing automated contract was found. Task 01-07-02 remains an explicit actual-evidence dependency; its expected nonzero strict audit is not a green acceptance result. Focused commands ran during their owning slices; the completed integrated suite and subsequent tooling regressions are recorded below. No full suite or large checkpoint hash walk was repeated for this audit. The seven explicit classified spec-less boundaries and two unresolved unclassified manual assumptions are reconciled in 01-SOURCE-AUDIT.md. The two research backstop truths abstain to human_needed if actual original audiovisual capture/browser review is insufficient. Descriptor-less project prohibitions remain flagged-unverified, not silently passed. ASVS1 high/critical threats block acceptance; T-01-SC is reserved across plans. -## Wave 0 Requirements +## Wave 0 Requirements — Complete (Automation) - Each implementation slice creates meaningful tests together with its production code; no empty stubs counted as validation. -- Create fidelity test fixtures covering changed/missing/added originals, output overlap, symlink/drive/case escape, reused session, tampered hash, invalid marker and unsupported schema. -- Create pure viewer tests including asymmetric durations, missing/buffering tracks, preserved playbackRate 1.0 and exclusive audio switching. +- Implemented fidelity test fixtures covering changed/missing/added originals, output overlap, symlink/drive/case escape, reused session, tampered hash, invalid marker and unsupported schema. +- Implemented pure viewer tests including asymmetric durations, missing/buffering tracks, preserved playbackRate 1.0 and exclusive audio switching. - No external test-framework installation required. Existing full suite remains available. ## Manual-Only Verifications @@ -72,14 +72,39 @@ The seven explicit classified spec-less boundaries and two unresolved unclassifi Unavailable/failed executions are recorded as open dependencies. Completing tools or preparing a bundle does not close EVID-02/EVID-04 or mark Phase 1 accepted. Source-backed later work may continue only under the existing roadmap exception. +## Measured Verification Evidence + +- Completed integrated run: `artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json` and `.log`, exit 0 in **782.049626 seconds**. Actual output records 556 Python tests (180 fidelity), 27 Node tests, 23 standalone managed observer checks, two separate HUD tests, all 51 managed entry-point invocations/build, 36 rendered Vulkan receipts with zero reported validation errors, SDL dummy-audio checks and 539 unchanged originals. Optional native-window checks were not enabled. Dummy audio does not establish audibility. +- Subsequent code-review fixes: `01-FIX-REPORT.md` and `artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/`. `python-fidelity.log` records **189 passing tests in 40.072 seconds**; `acceptance-final.log` records **29 passing acceptance tests** after the final standalone-transfer regression. These runs overlap; do not add their counts. `node-viewer-direct.log` records 27 behavior tests, `powershell.log` 18 synthetic checks under Linux-hosted PowerShell, and `original-preservation.log` 539 unchanged originals. The initial sandbox socket errors were resolved by the scoped local run; they are not represented as passes. +- Current discovery, without executing runtime loops: acceptance 29, capture 23, checkpoint 25, ledger 31, observation 7, review 21, scenarios 25, sessions 29: **190 current fidelity tests**. The final added acceptance test explains the difference from the earlier 189-test aggregate; it was executed in the final 29-test acceptance run. Discovery alone is not execution evidence. +- Review fixes exercise selected-receipt digest binding, pristine executable/inventory identity, named copy-state lifetime binding, sealed ledger/history projection including standalone transfer, and incomplete-session recovery without captured promotion. They strengthen existing covered contracts; independent review remains separate. +- Fresh immutable checkpoint: **11001 members**, `dist/fidelity/phase01`. Saved `01-review-fixes/readiness.json` reports `materials_ready: true`, `acceptance: human_needed` (command exit 0). Saved `acceptance.json` reports `errors: []`, **0/120**, all ten human findings pending (strict command exit 1). Original-DxWnd, native Windows and native Linux each retain 40 outstanding obligations. +- Focused tooling feedback is generally around 1–5 seconds (session/scenario/ledger around one second, checkpoint 4.742 seconds, review 5.234 seconds in owning summaries); observer process integration measured 19.126 seconds. The broad 40.072-second regression **exceeds** the proposed 30-second quick target. This is a latency WARNING, not a missing behavioral check or evidence acceptance. + ## Validation Sign-Off -- [ ] Final plans bind every task to automated checks or explicit human/native evidence -- [ ] Sampling continuity has no three consecutive tasks without automated verification -- [ ] New test files exist and execute nonzero test counts -- [ ] No watch-mode flags -- [ ] Quick feedback latency measured below 30 seconds -- [ ] Native/original capture limitations recorded -- [ ] nyquist_compliant updated only after the implemented validation contract is audited +- [x] Final plans bind every task to automated checks or explicit human/native evidence +- [x] Sampling continuity has no three consecutive tasks without automated verification +- [x] New test files exist and execute nonzero test counts +- [x] No watch-mode flags +- [ ] Broad quick feedback below 30 seconds — measured 40.072 seconds; WARNING retained +- [x] Native/original capture limitations recorded +- [x] Implemented automated validation contract audited; `nyquist_compliant` and `wave_0_complete` refer only to automation coverage +- [ ] Actual combined capture and human review complete — OPEN +- [ ] EVID requirements and Phase 01 acceptance complete — OPEN -**Approval:** Pending execution; final task bindings are planned, while nyquist_compliant and wave_0_complete remain false until actual implementation and validation are audited. +**Automation validation:** Validated on 2026-11-13 from executed tests and retained logs; no new automated gap found, no tests or implementation changed. The latency target remains a documented warning. `status: validated` does not advance the phase or promote any EVID requirement. + +**Acceptance dependencies:** A1, A2, EVID-02-unclassified, EVID-04-unclassified, P1, P2, P3, browser, paired_review and physical_input remain OPEN. Follow the single combined agenda in `docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md` and its Windows/Linux session procedures. Collect actual original-DxWnd/native Windows/native Linux recordings, physical input and audible checks, review real paired playback, return the identified local results, then rerun strict acceptance. The Linux preflight's missing usable display/audio is an explicit dependency. Cross-publish, Wine, headless/synthetic fixtures and preparation cannot close it. Independent review/security gates remain owned by their respective audits. + +## Final copy-state refinement + +All191 fidelity checks pass in43.355s after02d182f (26 scenario,23 capture,29 acceptance); missing/hash-only/wrong-size state records are explicitly rejected for both lifetimes. The43.355s aggregate still exceeds the30s quick target. No manual acceptance was promoted. + +## Validation Audit 2026-11-13 + +| Metric | Count | +|---|---| +| Gaps found | 0 | +| Resolved | 0 | +| Escalated | 0 | diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md index f077206..60de954 100644 --- a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md @@ -1,3 +1,5 @@ + + # Active quota checkpoint — 01-07, resume task3 verification This active handoff **takes precedence over01-07SUMMARY existence**. That summary diff --git a/docs/compatibility.md b/docs/compatibility.md index 48ae032..e5145d1 100644 --- a/docs/compatibility.md +++ b/docs/compatibility.md @@ -1,5 +1,21 @@ # Compatibility and validation +## Final phase 1 review closure + +All five review findings are independently verified fixed. The final copy-state +refinement is02d182f; all191 fidelity regressions pass in43.355s, with29 acceptance, +26 scenario and23 capture checks in the affected suites. Earlier review fixes +also pass27 Node and18 Linux-hosted PowerShell checks;539 originals stay unchanged. +The recovered full local suite passed782.049626s before these tooling-only review +fixes:556 Python,27 Node,23 observer,2 HUD,51 managed entry points and36 GPU render +receipts, zero Vulkan validation errors. The full GPU suite was not repeated for +these Python/collector fixes. Independent security audit closes22/22 planned +threats. Current fresh checkpoint is `dist/fidelity/phase01` (11,001 immutable +entries); exact current manifest/READY identities are recorded locally in +`artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json`. Earlier bundle +history is preserved locally. All120 actual original/native acceptance obligations +and ten named human findings remainOPEN. Final phase verification is pending. + ## Phase 1 final checkpoint — materials ready, runtime acceptance OPEN Fresh `dist/fidelity/phase01` readiness passes11,000 immutable members. Strict audit diff --git a/docs/decisions.md b/docs/decisions.md index 280ab33..5770a7d 100644 --- a/docs/decisions.md +++ b/docs/decisions.md @@ -1,5 +1,21 @@ # Decisions +## Final phase 1 review closure + +All five review findings are independently verified fixed. The final copy-state +refinement is02d182f; all191 fidelity regressions pass in43.355s, with29 acceptance, +26 scenario and23 capture checks in the affected suites. Earlier review fixes +also pass27 Node and18 Linux-hosted PowerShell checks;539 originals stay unchanged. +The recovered full local suite passed782.049626s before these tooling-only review +fixes:556 Python,27 Node,23 observer,2 HUD,51 managed entry points and36 GPU render +receipts, zero Vulkan validation errors. The full GPU suite was not repeated for +these Python/collector fixes. Independent security audit closes22/22 planned +threats. Current fresh checkpoint is `dist/fidelity/phase01` (11,001 immutable +entries); exact current manifest/READY identities are recorded locally in +`artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json`. Earlier bundle +history is preserved locally. All120 actual original/native acceptance obligations +and ten named human findings remainOPEN. Final phase verification is pending. + ## Final fidelity audit — phase 1 plan 01-07 Readiness verifies immutable prepared bytes and current copied materials; diff --git a/docs/progress.md b/docs/progress.md index 0f28dba..8960b2b 100644 --- a/docs/progress.md +++ b/docs/progress.md @@ -1,5 +1,21 @@ # Progress — 2026-11-07 +## Final phase 1 review closure + +All five review findings are independently verified fixed. The final copy-state +refinement is02d182f; all191 fidelity regressions pass in43.355s, with29 acceptance, +26 scenario and23 capture checks in the affected suites. Earlier review fixes +also pass27 Node and18 Linux-hosted PowerShell checks;539 originals stay unchanged. +The recovered full local suite passed782.049626s before these tooling-only review +fixes:556 Python,27 Node,23 observer,2 HUD,51 managed entry points and36 GPU render +receipts, zero Vulkan validation errors. The full GPU suite was not repeated for +these Python/collector fixes. Independent security audit closes22/22 planned +threats. Current fresh checkpoint is `dist/fidelity/phase01` (11,001 immutable +entries); exact current manifest/READY identities are recorded locally in +`artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json`. Earlier bundle +history is preserved locally. All120 actual original/native acceptance obligations +and ten named human findings remainOPEN. Final phase verification is pending. + ## Phase 1 final preparation — acceptance human_needed The fresh local `dist/fidelity/phase01` checkpoint passes readiness over11,000 diff --git a/docs/tasks.md b/docs/tasks.md index fd86efa..53111ef 100644 --- a/docs/tasks.md +++ b/docs/tasks.md @@ -1,5 +1,21 @@ # Tasks +## Final phase 1 review closure + +All five review findings are independently verified fixed. The final copy-state +refinement is02d182f; all191 fidelity regressions pass in43.355s, with29 acceptance, +26 scenario and23 capture checks in the affected suites. Earlier review fixes +also pass27 Node and18 Linux-hosted PowerShell checks;539 originals stay unchanged. +The recovered full local suite passed782.049626s before these tooling-only review +fixes:556 Python,27 Node,23 observer,2 HUD,51 managed entry points and36 GPU render +receipts, zero Vulkan validation errors. The full GPU suite was not repeated for +these Python/collector fixes. Independent security audit closes22/22 planned +threats. Current fresh checkpoint is `dist/fidelity/phase01` (11,001 immutable +entries); exact current manifest/READY identities are recorded locally in +`artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json`. Earlier bundle +history is preserved locally. All120 actual original/native acceptance obligations +and ten named human findings remainOPEN. Final phase verification is pending. + ## Phase 1 final preparation — human session pending - [x] Strict ready/audit tools:23 acceptance checks and24 checkpoint checks pass.