From f7e7033514cd343053df3a69f3f8642227989de9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cristian Cerroni Date: Sat, 14 Nov 2026 00:40:51 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] docs(01): persist final verification and pending combined-session UAT --- .planning/HANDOFF.json | 26 +- .planning/STATE.md | 14 +- .../.continue-here.md | 4 +- .../01-UAT.md | 70 ++++ .../01-VERIFICATION.md | 305 ++++++++++++++++++ .../HANDOFF.md | 4 +- docs/compatibility.md | 11 + docs/decisions.md | 11 + docs/progress.md | 11 + docs/tasks.md | 11 + 10 files changed, 440 insertions(+), 27 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-UAT.md create mode 100644 .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-VERIFICATION.md diff --git a/.planning/HANDOFF.json b/.planning/HANDOFF.json index 50a9333..fa64f83 100644 --- a/.planning/HANDOFF.json +++ b/.planning/HANDOFF.json @@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ "plan": 7, "task": 3, "total_tasks": 3, - "status": "paused", + "status": "consumed", "completed_tasks": [ { "id": 1, @@ -32,32 +32,22 @@ } ], "remaining_tasks": [ - { - "id": "verification", - "name": "Finalize typed verifier report/fingerprint, owner status and UAT/push", - "status": "in_progress" - }, { "id": 2, - "name": "Actual original/native combined human session", + "name": "Actual original/native combined session and strict acceptance", "status": "human_pending" } ], "blockers": [ - { - "type": "external", - "description": "15%quotareservepause; waitreset/userresume" - }, { "type": "human_action", - "description": "Actual120obligations/10namedhumanfindingspending" + "description": "Combined original/native session and ten named UAT checks remain pending; 0/120 accepted." } ], "background_processes": { - "test_processes": "none; completedfullsuiteandall191fidelitychecks", - "verifier": "Interrupted by root at15%pause to stop model work; reconcile report artifact onresume.", - "report_exists_at_snapshot": false, - "quota_watcher": "artifacts/gsd-quota" + "tests": "finished", + "verifier": "finished human_needed", + "quota_watcher": "running; no automatic resume" }, "async_jobs": [], "human_actions_pending": [ @@ -74,6 +64,6 @@ " M .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md", "?? tools.yaml" ], - "next_action": "Inspect01-VERIFICATION.md and owner verification.status; finish report/fingerprint/UAT ifneeded, commit/pushverified01-07reviewedwork; neverredo task3/fulltests orautoapprovehumanacceptance.", - "context_notes": "Quota guard explicitly requested pause at15%. Resume completed task01-07-03 and recovered fullsuite exit0 (782.049626s), then reviewed/fixed allfive source-integrity findings. Do NOT redo implementation or tests. Source commits through02d182f, review/coverage/security documentation71366e7. Fullsuite556Python/180fidelity,27Node,23observer,2HUD,51managedentrypoints,36GPUrenderedreceipts,zeroVulkanvalidationerrors,SDLdummychecks,539originalhashes. Latertooling-onlyfixes: all191fidelityregressions PASS43.355s; focused26scenario,23capture,29acceptance,27Node,18LinuxhostedPowerShell. All539originals unchanged. No runtime changes afterfullsuite; no need13minGPUrerun forcurrentPython/collector fixes.\nHistoricalreview5915128: CR01selected-vs-reviewedpath,CR02originalinventory/executablebinding,CR03copy-stateidentity,WR01viewerledgerprojection,WR02interruptedWindowsfinalization. Fixes5569bc2,bda35e5,6e5ee0b,548c97a,2608517,a821754. Independentre-reviewcaughtremaininghash-onlycopy-statebypass; RED48fca0d/GREEN02d182f requiresactual_checked_artifactwithrootinside_scenario_observation; callersupdated. Finalindependentre-reviewallfiveFIXED in01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md; dispositionopen0. Securityauditorfinal22/22mitigated, threats_open0 in01-SECURITY.md. Nyquistautomationcoveragevalidatedall15taskbindings; manualacceptanceopen;191fidelityaggregate43.355sec exceeds30secquicktargethonestly. UIreviewdisabledconfigfalse. No remainingknowncode/securityblockers.\nCurrentfreshfinalbundle dist/fidelity/phase01 has11001immutableentries. Currenthashes/readinessreceipt artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json. readyexit0true,strictauditexit1 errors[] accepted0/120,10humanpending; logs artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/readiness-final.json,acceptance-final.json,python-fidelity-final.log. Oldbundlespreserved phase01-pre-review-48100025 andphase01-pre-copy-artifact-7ceebcb3. ActualLinuxfailedpreflightimportedcurrentbundle/results/imported. Runtimepackage source446930d dirty/diff90cef956 unchanged; source/docscommitsmustnotrelabelitsidentity. Original/nativeWindows+DxWnd andphysicalLinuxvisible/audible/browserreviewremainonecombinedhuman session pending. Humanonlycollects/observes/returns; agent-ownedexactnormalizationmapping incheckpoint-session.md. No capture request issued yet because finalphaseverification/handoffpending.\nFinal typed verifier phase01_final_verification was dispatched at21%; quota15% interrupted it, instructedfinishonlyboundedhuman_neededreport/fingerprint thenreturn. It had readall7musthaves/summaries, checked25capabilities/33requirements/0unmapped/6groups/33rows,16/16decisioncoverage,40sourcefilesnoskip/debtscan. A mandatoryMVPgoalformatguard exposed existingROADMAPMode:mvp plainproseGoal. Rootauthorizedformat-only identicalintentuserstory and modifiedROADMAP.md uncommitted: As a tester, I want to reproduce identified original/port comparison scenarios, so that I understand exactly what the current reconstruction proves on each native platform. Validatorvalidtrue; no scope/successcriteriamodified. OneverifiercommandusedwrongunittestclassFidelityAcceptance (loadererror,correctclassAcceptanceTests); twoothernamedbehaviorcheckspassed; don'tmislabelthatcommandassuccess. Priorfulltargeted29passestablishactualcoverage.\nNEXT: Reconcile currentverifier's 01-VERIFICATION.md and CLI verification.status; ifreport/fingerprintabsentfinishthat ONLY beforeanynewphase. FingerprintmustbeownerCLIgenerated, notmanual. Oncehuman_neededstatusvalid, persistUATfromnamedhumanitems, updateSTATE/consumedhandoffs, commitverifiedreport+goalmetadata+handoffdocs andpush verifiedsource/tooling toauthorizedGitea/main. Lastpushedhead remainsd18f551; later01-07/task3/reviewfix/auditcommits arelocalawaitingfinalverification. Preserveunrelatedtools.yaml. Do notadvancephase2orclaimPhase1accepted; allEVIDIDsPending0/120humanacceptance. No source changesuncommittedexceptROADMAPformatandpossiblynewverifierreport.\nNativeagents/sourcewritesallfinishedexceptverifierreportbeingclosed. Quota watcher runs and actual15%steeringworks. Noauto-resume; usermust $gsd-resume-workafterreset. Don'tspendquota rereadingmassiveGSDscriptbodies orrerunningfinished13minfullsuite. Existinglocalpackages/media/originalcopiesstaylocal, noCI/uploads. MaintracksGitea/main, scoped.gitwriteescalation; retainhistoricalhandoffsmarkconsumedratherthandelete (priorautomaticreviewrejecteddeletion).\nRootinterruptedverifieratfinalpause tostopallmodelwork. Reconcileactualreportfileifpresent; ifabsentfinishboundedreport/fingerprintafterreset.\n" + "next_action": "Use $gsd-verify-work 1 and docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md for one combined actual human session; do not repeat completed implementation/tests/review or advance Phase2 automatically.", + "context_notes": "Quota guard explicitly requested pause at15%. Resume completed task01-07-03 and recovered fullsuite exit0 (782.049626s), then reviewed/fixed allfive source-integrity findings. Do NOT redo implementation or tests. Source commits through02d182f, review/coverage/security documentation71366e7. Fullsuite556Python/180fidelity,27Node,23observer,2HUD,51managedentrypoints,36GPUrenderedreceipts,zeroVulkanvalidationerrors,SDLdummychecks,539originalhashes. Latertooling-onlyfixes: all191fidelityregressions PASS43.355s; focused26scenario,23capture,29acceptance,27Node,18LinuxhostedPowerShell. All539originals unchanged. No runtime changes afterfullsuite; no need13minGPUrerun forcurrentPython/collector fixes.\nHistoricalreview5915128: CR01selected-vs-reviewedpath,CR02originalinventory/executablebinding,CR03copy-stateidentity,WR01viewerledgerprojection,WR02interruptedWindowsfinalization. Fixes5569bc2,bda35e5,6e5ee0b,548c97a,2608517,a821754. Independentre-reviewcaughtremaininghash-onlycopy-statebypass; RED48fca0d/GREEN02d182f requiresactual_checked_artifactwithrootinside_scenario_observation; callersupdated. Finalindependentre-reviewallfiveFIXED in01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md; dispositionopen0. Securityauditorfinal22/22mitigated, threats_open0 in01-SECURITY.md. Nyquistautomationcoveragevalidatedall15taskbindings; manualacceptanceopen;191fidelityaggregate43.355sec exceeds30secquicktargethonestly. UIreviewdisabledconfigfalse. No remainingknowncode/securityblockers.\nCurrentfreshfinalbundle dist/fidelity/phase01 has11001immutableentries. Currenthashes/readinessreceipt artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json. readyexit0true,strictauditexit1 errors[] accepted0/120,10humanpending; logs artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/readiness-final.json,acceptance-final.json,python-fidelity-final.log. Oldbundlespreserved phase01-pre-review-48100025 andphase01-pre-copy-artifact-7ceebcb3. ActualLinuxfailedpreflightimportedcurrentbundle/results/imported. Runtimepackage source446930d dirty/diff90cef956 unchanged; source/docscommitsmustnotrelabelitsidentity. Original/nativeWindows+DxWnd andphysicalLinuxvisible/audible/browserreviewremainonecombinedhuman session pending. Humanonlycollects/observes/returns; agent-ownedexactnormalizationmapping incheckpoint-session.md. No capture request issued yet because finalphaseverification/handoffpending.\nFinal typed verifier phase01_final_verification was dispatched at21%; quota15% interrupted it, instructedfinishonlyboundedhuman_neededreport/fingerprint thenreturn. It had readall7musthaves/summaries, checked25capabilities/33requirements/0unmapped/6groups/33rows,16/16decisioncoverage,40sourcefilesnoskip/debtscan. A mandatoryMVPgoalformatguard exposed existingROADMAPMode:mvp plainproseGoal. Rootauthorizedformat-only identicalintentuserstory and modifiedROADMAP.md uncommitted: As a tester, I want to reproduce identified original/port comparison scenarios, so that I understand exactly what the current reconstruction proves on each native platform. Validatorvalidtrue; no scope/successcriteriamodified. OneverifiercommandusedwrongunittestclassFidelityAcceptance (loadererror,correctclassAcceptanceTests); twoothernamedbehaviorcheckspassed; don'tmislabelthatcommandassuccess. Priorfulltargeted29passestablishactualcoverage.\nNEXT: Reconcile currentverifier's 01-VERIFICATION.md and CLI verification.status; ifreport/fingerprintabsentfinishthat ONLY beforeanynewphase. FingerprintmustbeownerCLIgenerated, notmanual. Oncehuman_neededstatusvalid, persistUATfromnamedhumanitems, updateSTATE/consumedhandoffs, commitverifiedreport+goalmetadata+handoffdocs andpush verifiedsource/tooling toauthorizedGitea/main. Lastpushedhead remainsd18f551; later01-07/task3/reviewfix/auditcommits arelocalawaitingfinalverification. Preserveunrelatedtools.yaml. Do notadvancephase2orclaimPhase1accepted; allEVIDIDsPending0/120humanacceptance. No source changesuncommittedexceptROADMAPformatandpossiblynewverifierreport.\nNativeagents/sourcewritesallfinishedexceptverifierreportbeingclosed. Quota watcher runs and actual15%steeringworks. Noauto-resume; usermust $gsd-resume-workafterreset. Don'tspendquota rereadingmassiveGSDscriptbodies orrerunningfinished13minfullsuite. Existinglocalpackages/media/originalcopiesstaylocal, noCI/uploads. MaintracksGitea/main, scoped.gitwriteescalation; retainhistoricalhandoffsmarkconsumedratherthandelete (priorautomaticreviewrejecteddeletion).\nRootinterruptedverifieratfinalpause tostopallmodelwork. Reconcileactualreportfileifpresent; ifabsentfinishboundedreport/fingerprintafterreset.\n\n2026-11-14 final typed verifier completed: human_needed,29/42verified13uncertain,all10namedhumanitems saved01-UAT.md. Ownerstatusacceptedreport; verificationfingerprintrefreshedafterfinalstatusnotes. Goalformatfebb4a9committed. Remainingworkisactualcombinedhumanverification, notcoding/fulltests.\n" } diff --git a/.planning/STATE.md b/.planning/STATE.md index 957d40e..bd0f02f 100644 --- a/.planning/STATE.md +++ b/.planning/STATE.md @@ -2,12 +2,12 @@ gsd_state_version: "1.0" current_phase: 01 current_phase_name: Reproducible Fidelity Baseline -status: ready_for_verification -stopped_at: Quota15%pause after review closure; final verification/fingerprint/UAT and push pending -last_updated: "2026-11-13T22:22:35.261Z" +status: awaiting_human_verification +stopped_at: Phase1 verified human_needed; ten UAT checks and combined actual session pending +last_updated: "2026-11-14T05:39:47.960Z" last_activity: 2026-11-13 last_activity_desc: 01-07 autonomous preparation verified; actual human acceptance pending 0/120 -state_head: 02d182f35de643f9d68699b2fff1d219dd132edb +state_head: febb4a9d98071b19998bcecfab4a236d9c0adfce progress: total_phases: 8 completed_phases: 0 @@ -108,6 +108,6 @@ No original-required category deferred outside full reconstruction. Later phases ## Session Continuity -Last session: 2026-11-13T22:22:35.231Z -Stopped at: Review/security/coverage closed; final verifier report and human-needed handoff pending at15%quota -Resume file: docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md +Last session: 2026-11-14T05:39:45.079Z +Stopped at: Phase1 verified human_needed; ten UAT checks and combined actual session pending +Resume file: .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-UAT.md diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/.continue-here.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/.continue-here.md index 9fa696b..3dc0c61 100644 --- a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/.continue-here.md +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/.continue-here.md @@ -1,10 +1,12 @@ + + --- context: phase phase: 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline plan: "07" task: 3 total_tasks: 3 -status: paused +status: consumed last_updated: "2026-11-13T22:26:46.798618+00:00" --- diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-UAT.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-UAT.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..00ef7e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-UAT.md @@ -0,0 +1,70 @@ +--- +status: testing +phase: 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline +source: [01-VERIFICATION.md] +started: 2026-11-14T05:39:44.958968+00:00 +updated: 2026-11-14T05:39:44.958968+00:00 +--- + +## Current Test + +number: 1 +name: A1 — Capture and observe the isolated original through the selected DxWnd setup +expected: | + Complete 40 original-Windows-DxWnd obligations; observe moving game imagery and intelligible game audio, retaining actual executable/profile/copy inventories and wrapper/configuration limitations. +awaiting: user response + +## Tests + +### 1. A1 — Capture and observe the isolated original through the selected DxWnd setup +expected: Complete 40 original-Windows-DxWnd obligations; observe moving game imagery and intelligible game audio, retaining actual executable/profile/copy inventories and wrapper/configuration limitations. +result: [pending] + +### 2. A2 — Exercise actual paired recordings in the identified browser +expected: Both real recordings decode, play at actual speed, seek to their own observed events, preserve full tails and switch exclusive audio without concealing elapsed time. +result: [pending] + +### 3. EVID-02-unclassified — Review original capture boundaries and limitations +expected: Document observed original/DxWnd launch, crop, aspect, timing, recording boundaries and retained/fresh lifetimes for the actual reference captures. +result: [pending] + +### 4. EVID-04-unclassified — Collect and inspect both native platform routes +expected: Complete 40 native Windows and 40 native Linux obligations with actual OS/GPU/driver/Vulkan/SDL/source/package/resource identity and observed route/input/audio continuity. +result: [pending] + +### 5. P1 — Resolve the original-preservation prohibition explicitly +expected: Confirm authoritative originals were never executed or changed; compare all 539 recorded hashes and generated-copy pre/retained/post inventories after the session. +result: [pending] + +### 6. P2 — Resolve the honest-comparison prohibition explicitly +expected: Confirm genuine original media, no retiming or concealed drift, no mixed simultaneous soundtracks, and visible review gain/derivation provenance. +result: [pending] + +### 7. P3 — Resolve the history/full-scope/native-transparency prohibition explicitly +expected: Confirm all 33 requirements and unimplemented content stay visible; conflicting/superseded evidence and native/Wine/component/cross-publish distinctions are preserved after reconciliation. +result: [pending] + +### 8. browser — Review the complete local comparison interface +expected: With real captures, verify readable independent clocks/drift, keyboard controls, raw unobstructed default views, optional annotations/differences and visible loading/error/tail states. +result: [pending] + +### 9. paired_review — Compare all corresponding actual recordings and record discrepancies +expected: Review matched events, imagery and sound across the required cases, retaining raw drift and justified system-specific observations without invented tolerances. +result: [pending] + +### 10. physical_input — Exercise visible native gameplay and actual audible devices +expected: On Linux and Windows use physical supported inputs through lab → VR04 → lab → outside, natural/skipped and fresh/retained cases, held input, banked jumps, landing and idle; confirm real display/audio output. +result: [pending] + +## Summary + +total: 10 +passed: 0 +issues: 0 +pending: 10 +skipped: 0 +blocked: 0 + +## Gaps + +No implementation issues reported in this UAT session. All ten actual human checks remain pending; 0/120 capture obligations are accepted. Follow docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md as one combined session. Prepared materials and prior tests do not supply human approval. diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-VERIFICATION.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-VERIFICATION.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..25835d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-VERIFICATION.md @@ -0,0 +1,305 @@ +--- +phase: 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline +verified: 2026-11-14T05:34:19Z +status: human_needed +score: 29/42 must-haves verified +covered_files: [".planning/REQUIREMENTS.md",".planning/ROADMAP.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-01-PLAN.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-01-SUMMARY.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-02-PLAN.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-02-SUMMARY.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-03-PLAN.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-03-SUMMARY.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-04-PLAN.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-04-SUMMARY.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-05-PLAN.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-05-SUMMARY.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-06-PLAN.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-06-SUMMARY.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-07-PLAN.md",".planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-07-SUMMARY.md","artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json","artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.log","artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/acceptance-final.json","artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/python-fidelity-final.log","artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/readiness-final.json","artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json","docs/compatibility.md","docs/decisions.md","docs/evidence/README.md","docs/evidence/capabilities.json","docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md","docs/evidence/linux-session.md","docs/evidence/phase01-baseline.md","docs/evidence/scenarios.json","docs/evidence/windows-session.md","docs/original-manifest.json","docs/progress.md","docs/tasks.md","scripts/collect-fidelity-linux.sh","scripts/collect-fidelity-windows.cmd","scripts/collect-fidelity-windows.ps1","scripts/env.sh","scripts/prepare-fidelity-checkpoint.sh","scripts/test.sh","src/GamePort/Application/FidelityObservation.cs","src/GamePort/Program.cs","tests/GamePort.FidelityObservationTests/GamePort.FidelityObservationTests.csproj","tests/GamePort.FidelityObservationTests/Program.cs","tests/fidelity-viewer.test.mjs","tests/fidelity-windows.Tests.ps1","tests/test_fidelity_acceptance.py","tests/test_fidelity_capture.py","tests/test_fidelity_checkpoint.py","tests/test_fidelity_ledger.py","tests/test_fidelity_observation.py","tests/test_fidelity_review.py","tests/test_fidelity_scenarios.py","tests/test_fidelity_sessions.py","tools/recon/fidelity.py","tools/recon/fidelity_acceptance.py","tools/recon/fidelity_capture.py","tools/recon/fidelity_checkpoint.py","tools/recon/fidelity_ledger.py","tools/recon/fidelity_receipts.py","tools/recon/fidelity_review.py","tools/recon/fidelity_viewer/index.html","tools/recon/fidelity_viewer/style.css","tools/recon/fidelity_viewer/viewer.mjs","tools/recon/inventory.py"] +covered_digest: "v4:sha256:70961b746a2cfc2cdb08a10750338dafb95fa17bd4ab0ecb4e3453c6c1075bcc" +behavior_unverified: 0 +overrides_applied: 0 +decision_coverage: + honored: 16 + total: 16 + not_honored: [] +non_inferable_checks: + - truth: "Actual original-DxWnd moving game imagery and intelligible audio are observed and reviewed with wrapper/config limitations recorded." + status: uncertain + reason: insufficient_spec + human_check: A1 + - truth: "Actual paired recordings decode, seek and switch exclusive audio in the identified local browser without concealing elapsed time." + status: uncertain + reason: insufficient_spec + human_check: A2 +unverified_prohibitions: + - id: P1 + statement: "MUST NOT sacrifice authoritative original bytes or execute the authoritative installation to make reference collection convenient." + status: unverified + flag: "unverified-prohibition — human review recommended" + - id: P2 + statement: "MUST NOT manufacture apparent parity by retiming recordings, hiding drift, mixing both soundtracks or presenting synthetic media as an original reference." + status: unverified + flag: "unverified-prohibition — human review recommended" + - id: P3 + statement: "MUST NOT erase contradictory history, hide unimplemented required content or turn missing evidence into a fidelity-completion claim." + status: unverified + flag: "unverified-prohibition — human review recommended" +human_verification: + - test: "A1 — Capture and observe the isolated original through the selected DxWnd setup" + expected: "Complete 40 original-Windows-DxWnd obligations; observe moving game imagery and intelligible game audio, retaining actual executable/profile/copy inventories and wrapper/configuration limitations." + why_human: "Original execution and audiovisual truth are unobserved; the backstop abstains with insufficient_spec." + - test: "A2 — Exercise actual paired recordings in the identified browser" + expected: "Both real recordings decode, play at actual speed, seek to their own observed events, preserve full tails and switch exclusive audio without concealing elapsed time." + why_human: "Controller tests use media doubles; they cannot establish real codec/browser/physical-audio behavior. Backstop: insufficient_spec." + - test: "EVID-02-unclassified — Review original capture boundaries and limitations" + expected: "Document observed original/DxWnd launch, crop, aspect, timing, recording boundaries and retained/fresh lifetimes for the actual reference captures." + why_human: "This flagged assumption cannot be inferred from prepared settings or synthetic metadata." + - test: "EVID-04-unclassified — Collect and inspect both native platform routes" + expected: "Complete 40 native Windows and 40 native Linux obligations with actual OS/GPU/driver/Vulkan/SDL/source/package/resource identity and observed route/input/audio continuity." + why_human: "Windows is cross-published only; current Linux TTY/auto_null preflight cannot capture native physical gameplay." + - test: "P1 — Resolve the original-preservation prohibition explicitly" + expected: "Confirm authoritative originals were never executed or changed; compare all 539 recorded hashes and generated-copy pre/retained/post inventories after the session." + why_human: "Descriptor-less unresolved prohibition requires explicit disposition; current preserved hashes do not prove future session conduct." + - test: "P2 — Resolve the honest-comparison prohibition explicitly" + expected: "Confirm genuine original media, no retiming or concealed drift, no mixed simultaneous soundtracks, and visible review gain/derivation provenance." + why_human: "Unverified-prohibition — human review recommended; genuine playback and perceived audiovisual comparison require observation." + - test: "P3 — Resolve the history/full-scope/native-transparency prohibition explicitly" + expected: "Confirm all 33 requirements and unimplemented content stay visible; conflicting/superseded evidence and native/Wine/component/cross-publish distinctions are preserved after reconciliation." + why_human: "Unverified-prohibition — human review recommended; final returned-evidence reconciliation requires explicit judgment." + - test: "browser — Review the complete local comparison interface" + expected: "With real captures, verify readable independent clocks/drift, keyboard controls, raw unobstructed default views, optional annotations/differences and visible loading/error/tail states." + why_human: "No actual browser visual/usability/codec review has been performed." + - test: "paired_review — Compare all corresponding actual recordings and record discrepancies" + expected: "Review matched events, imagery and sound across the required cases, retaining raw drift and justified system-specific observations without invented tolerances." + why_human: "No corresponding original/native pair or completed visual/audible comparison exists." + - test: "physical_input — Exercise visible native gameplay and actual audible devices" + expected: "On Linux and Windows use physical supported inputs through lab → VR04 → lab → outside, natural/skipped and fresh/retained cases, held input, banked jumps, landing and idle; confirm real display/audio output." + why_human: "Injected/headless/GPU/dummy-audio fixtures prove narrower behavior and cannot satisfy physical-input or audibility acceptance." +--- + +# Phase 1: Reproducible Fidelity Baseline Verification Report + +**Phase Goal:** As a tester, I want to reproduce identified original/port comparison scenarios, so that I understand exactly what the current reconstruction proves on each native platform. + +**Verified:** 2026-11-14T05:34:19Z +**Status:** human_needed +**Re-verification:** No existing VERIFICATION.md; completion of the interrupted initial verification after the MVP goal-format correction (`febb4a9`). No scope change or override. + +## User Flow Coverage + +| Step | Expected | Evidence | Status | +|---|---|---|---| +| Open the local checkpoint and inspect identities | Identified offline original copy, both port packages, complete agenda and viewer | Final readiness receipt: 11,001 immutable members; materials_ready true | VERIFIED for preparation | +| Reproduce isolated original scenarios | Moving imagery, intelligible audio, input/events and retained/fresh provenance from the actual selected DxWnd configuration | Collector/guide prepared; no returned original gameplay captures; 0/40 accepted | UNCERTAIN — WARNING; A1, EVID-02, P1 | +| Repeat matching native Linux/Windows routes | Same route/cases with physical input, real display/audio and exact runtime identities | Windows cross-publish only; real Linux preflight failed without selected X11/real audio; 0/80 accepted | UNCERTAIN — WARNING; EVID-04, physical_input | +| Inspect paired playback | Actual corresponding media with independent event times, exposed drift and exclusive audio | Controller is implemented/tested; prepared viewer contains no actual pair | UNCERTAIN — WARNING; A2, browser, paired_review, P2 | +| Trace what each capability proves | Source/implementation/platform/scope/discrepancy/remaining-acceptance links across the full game | 25 capabilities, six groups, all 33 requirements; current/history preserved | VERIFIED for traceability; P3 final judgment pending | +| Understand the reconstruction on each native platform | Actual identified original/native evidence plus honest discrepancies and unresolved limitations | Audit: errors [], 0/120 accepted; ten named human findings pending | UNCERTAIN — WARNING; user-story outcome remains open | + +The MVP user flow is incomplete. No new technical runtime/test run was started to bypass it. The implementation evidence below records inspected code and already completed local verification; it does not constitute manual acceptance. Phase 1 is not passed and Phase 2 is not advanced by this report. + +## Goal Achievement + +### Observable Truths + +Roadmap criteria are retained in full; PLAN truths add detail and do not reduce them. VERIFIED on a tooling truth certifies its bounded implementation, not original/native fidelity. UNCERTAIN items request human verification rather than asserting missing implementation. No accepted override exists. + +| ID | Truth | Status | Evidence | +|---|---|---|---| +| SC1 | A reviewer can verify every original against the recorded inventory and run investigation/reference copies without altering the original installation. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | `verify_inventory`/staging and saved 539-file check prove current preservation; actual generated-copy reference execution and P1 disposition remain unobserved. | +| SC2 | A tester can reproduce identified whole-original reference scenarios from an isolated generated installation and inspect corresponding input/events, images and audio where applicable; unavailable execution keeps this criterion open. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Actual original-DxWnd captures absent; explicit access limitation leaves 40 obligations open (A1/EVID-02). | +| SC3 | A reviewer can trace every full-game capability from original evidence through current implementation, platform receipts, discrepancies and its remaining acceptance condition. | VERIFIED | Ledger validator/export/renderer connect 25 capabilities to all 33 requirements, source paths, implementation revisions, scoped platform records, differences and open acceptance. | +| SC4 | Testers can repeat the same baseline movement/route scenarios on native Linux and native Windows with exact revision identities; Wine/cross-publish receipts remain separately labeled and cannot close missing native execution. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | No accepted current native baseline capture on either platform: 40 Linux + 40 Windows obligations remain open (EVID-04/physical_input). | +| 01.1 | A reviewer can stage and identify a pristine generated original installation without altering any original byte (EVID-01, D-15). | VERIFIED | `fidelity.py:stage` calls `stage_original`; `verify_inventory` compares all recorded file identities before/after isolated copying. Saved original-preservation log verifies 539 unchanged originals. Actual DxWnd execution remains separately pending. | +| 01.2 | The protocol requires continuous lab → VR04 → lab → outside and focused dialogue-return, left/right banked-jump, landing and idle captures per D-01 and D-04. | VERIFIED | `scenarios.json` requires continuous lab → VR04 → lab → outside plus dialogue-return, left/right bank, landing/idle; `validate_scenario_contract`/`audit_scenarios` enforce obligations. | +| 01.3 | Natural/skipped dialogue and fresh/retained entry are equally required, independently identified dimensions per D-02 and D-03. | VERIFIED | Eight case IDs independently cross fresh/retained, natural/skipped and ordinary/held-input; scenario validator rejects collapsed dimensions. | +| 01.4 | Equal, nested, symlink-aliased and Windows case-aliased source/output paths fail before any staging write; sibling paths merely sharing a textual prefix remain distinct. | VERIFIED | `separated_roots`, symlink rejection and canonical path checks precede staging writes; session regressions cover equal/nested/case/symlink/prefix cases. | +| 01.5 | Empty/missing inventories fail; single-file fixtures round-trip, while changed, missing and added files invalidate identity. | VERIFIED | `identify_tree` rejects empty inventory; exact file-list comparison rejects changed/missing/added files; single-file round-trip regressions are active. | +| 01.6 | Manifest order is canonical relative POSIX path order; case-colliding identities fail instead of acquiring filesystem-dependent order. | VERIFIED | `identify_tree` sorts POSIX paths and rejects casefold collisions; canonical-order regression checks actual list/digest values. | +| 01.7 | Interrupted staging/import leaves an explicit incomplete diagnostic and no completed receipt; simultaneous same-session allocation has one winner, and duplicate receipt imports are idempotent only for byte-identical content. | VERIFIED | `_reserve`, exclusive writes, incomplete siblings and atomic publication implement allocation/import ownership. Named concurrency/interruption/duplicate regressions in `test_fidelity_sessions.py` pass in saved 191-test run. | +| 01.8 | Typed receipt validation retains failures and missing evidence as open acceptance; D-13 Windows availability is not a runtime receipt. | VERIFIED | `validate_receipt`/`audit_scenarios` separate failure, synthetic, component, Wine and native kinds. Current real failed Linux receipt remains OPEN; availability is no receipt. | +| 02.1 | A tester opens a local scenario with paired original/port playback and corresponding image, audio and input/event links per D-05. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Exporter/controller support paired validated receipts, but final `review.json` has no actual original/native pair. A1/A2/browser/paired_review remain human checks. | +| 02.2 | Raw captures are unobstructed by default; annotations and provenance-bound image differences are optional overlays per D-06. | VERIFIED | Controller defaults `annotations`/`difference` false; corresponding Node overlay/provenance regressions cover opt-in state. Actual visual unobstruction remains part of browser review. | +| 02.3 | Selecting an event seeks each recording to its own observed time; both play at actual speed with separate elapsed clocks, event drift and playback drift per D-07. | VERIFIED | Named Node event-selection/drift/readiness tests assert separate observed times, rate 1, independent elapsed clocks and exposed drift. This verifies controller behavior, not actual codec/browser playback. | +| 02.4 | The reviewer switches corresponding original/port audio with at most one source audible and visible review gain per D-08. | VERIFIED | Named exclusive-soundtrack/gain tests assert both muted before selecting one and labeled review-only gain. Physical audibility remains pending. | +| 02.5 | Missing, buffering, rejected-play, decoding and asymmetric-end states remain visible and preserve the full recording tails. | VERIFIED | Named rejected-play/buffering/decode/asymmetric-end tests assert paired pause, visible cause and resumable full longer tail. Real browser observation is still A2. | +| 03.1 | Reviewers browse movement, contacts, gadgets, progression, visuals and audio with requirement/source/scenario/platform links per D-09. | VERIFIED | `GROUPS` and ledger contain movement, contacts, gadgets, progression, visuals and audio; exported capability links include source/requirement/scenario/platform. | +| 03.2 | Each capability leads with working behavior, verified scope/platform, known differences and remaining acceptance per D-10. | VERIFIED | Capability rows carry working summary, verified scope, implementation revision, differences and open acceptance; renderer presents supplied facts. | +| 03.3 | Current applicable evidence precedes expandable explicitly superseded revision history per D-11; applicability uses content/scope/platform rather than newest date. | VERIFIED | Scope/content/platform applicability and explicit supersession retain current/history. Final reviewed fix verifies both projections survive bundle export; newest date is not acceptance. | +| 03.4 | Discrepancies order blocking/disruptive failures before subtler differences and missing verification per D-12; all missing evidence keeps acceptance open. | VERIFIED | `IMPACTS` orders blocking/disruptive/subtle/missing_verification; acceptance stays open. Strict current audit has no accepted runtime obligations. | +| 03.5 | All 33 full-game requirements have capability coverage even when unimplemented; an empty ledger fails and one capability remains renderable. | VERIFIED | Ledger covers 25 capabilities and all 33 requirements across six groups; validator rejects empty ledger, renderer supports a singleton. Full-game implementation is not claimed. | +| 03.6 | Equal receipt/content identities merge only when the record bytes match; conflicts remain explicit, and duplicate history rows never silently overwrite evidence. | VERIFIED | Canonical byte conflict checks prevent contradictory receipt/content deduplication and preserve history; ledger regression assertions cover conflicts. | +| 03.7 | Equal-priority entries have deterministic stable ID ordering; explicit supersession cycles and unresolved contradictory current claims fail validation. | VERIFIED | Stable ID sorting, supersession-cycle and contradictory-current validation are implemented and covered by active ledger regressions. | +| 04.1 | An optional passive observer records actual native port input/control/scene events across the continuous route per D-01, without changing gameplay or scene lifetime. | VERIFIED | `Program.cs:18-30` owns one optional observer across outer Run continuations; post-Step calls at 1328-1333 use actual accepted input/state. Managed/process regressions cover observer wiring; no physical route acceptance inferred. | +| 04.2 | Natural/skipped and fresh/retained runs have distinct case identities, with one monotonic session across actual retained continuations per D-02 and D-03. | VERIFIED | One retained observer/monotonic session spans Run continuations; distinct case identity and simulation ticks are preserved. Existing observer tests exercise clock/order/continuation. | +| 04.3 | Held/neutral input, banked jump, landing and idle observations retain their real owner/tick/time per D-04; injected smoke fixtures stay separately classified. | VERIFIED | Actual raw SDL/input/state/control calls include owner/tick/time; smoke/injected paths are separately classified. Managed and process assertions check payload/receipt interoperability. | +| 04.4 | An output failure leaves the observation incomplete and visible rather than reporting acceptance or changing movement/state to finish the recording. | VERIFIED | Observer write failure emits an incomplete diagnostic without completing acceptance; standalone managed failure regressions exercise this path. | +| 05.1 | One complete local checkpoint bundle contains identified port packages, a verified generated original copy, scenarios, viewer and result collection per D-14. | VERIFIED | Final checkpoint receipt identifies 11,001 immutable members, both sealed packages, generated original seed, protocol, viewer and result collectors; readiness true. | +| 05.2 | The available Windows PC is treated as a pending execution environment per D-13; actual OS/GPU/driver/tool identities are collected during the session. | VERIFIED | Windows session guide/collector require actual OS/GPU/driver/tool observations; no native Windows receipt exists. Pending environment is explicitly distinguished from execution. | +| 05.3 | The original launches only from a generated copy through the user's identified DxWnd binary/exported profile, separately from native port receipts, per D-15. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Collector protects original-pristine, copies a writable run, retains selected DxWnd/profile and requires GUI launch. Actual user-selected DxWnd execution/configuration is unobserved; A1/P1 pending. | +| 05.4 | All original-reference and port materials are prepared before one combined session per D-16; preparation does not close EVID-02 or EVID-04. | VERIFIED | Readiness validates both package identities and complete 80-obligation Windows agenda; guide also requires 40 Linux obligations. `ready()` always reports human_needed. | +| 05.5 | Launcher preflight or recording failure produces an actionable local failure receipt without inventing successful capture or downloading dependencies. | VERIFIED | Collector/preflight failures retain diagnostic/open states. Actual Linux TTY/null-audio failure is retained; PowerShell recovery checks cover aborted incomplete collection without invented success. | +| 06.1 | An identified native Linux package yields actual input/event and audiovisual captures where execution is available; synthetic/headless replays remain distinct (EVID-04). | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Native Linux collector invokes identified package/observer and real recorder only after preflight. Current host has no selected real display/audio and produced failed preflight, with no gameplay capture. | +| 06.2 | Continuous route and focused captures cover all natural/skipped, fresh/retained and ordinary/edge cells per D-01–D-04, with missing executions explicitly open. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Matrix/scenario implementation requires all 40 Linux obligations and tracks missing cases, but no physical Linux route/focused capture is accepted. | +| 06.3 | Physical input/audio and real visible gameplay require actual native receipts/human review; dummy audio and window-only fixtures cannot complete acceptance. | VERIFIED | Preflight rejects dummy/null devices; native review requires real input/audibility/visibility. Strict audit cannot accept headless/synthetic fixtures. | +| 07.1 | One fully prepared combined session covers original-DxWnd and native Windows cases, local Linux review and real paired playback, per D-13–D-16. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Materials and one-session agenda are ready; the combined original/native/browser session has not occurred. | +| 07.2 | Every required original-reference and native Linux/Windows case has exact revision/package/resource/media and observation provenance; absent or failed cases keep EVID-02/EVID-04 open. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Strict audit reports 0/120 accepted, no structural errors and every missing obligation. Exact successful runtime/media provenance cannot yet be verified. | +| 07.3 | Paired review of actual original/port captures applies D-05–D-08 and publishes raw drift, discrepancies and audible/visible checks. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | No actual paired recordings or witnessed drift/audio/visual review returned; paired_review/P2 remain pending. | +| 07.4 | Current capabilities/history/discrepancies are reconciled to returned receipts per D-09–D-12, with full matrix completeness per D-01–D-04. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Current baseline and ledger honestly retain missing evidence; returned-receipt reconciliation awaits actual collection and agent-owned normalization/import. | +| 07.5 | Actual original-DxWnd moving game imagery and intelligible audio are observed and reviewed with wrapper/config limitations recorded. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | UNCERTAIN — insufficient_spec: no observed original-DxWnd moving imagery/intelligible audio and wrapper review (A1); metadata fixtures cannot prove it. | +| 07.6 | Actual paired recordings decode, seek and switch exclusive audio in the identified local browser without concealing elapsed time. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | UNCERTAIN — insufficient_spec: no actual identified-browser decode/seek/exclusive-audio observation (A2); Node media doubles cannot prove browser codecs or audibility. | + +**Score:** 29/42 truths verified; 13 UNCERTAIN. **Present-but-behavior-unverified invariants:** 0. Existing behavioral regressions exercise the tooling transitions; the unverified items concern actual external execution, media, physical experience and final reconciliation. A1/A2 separately abstain with `insufficient_spec`. + +### Required Artifacts and Wiring Evidence + +Owner `query verify.artifacts` independently returned exit 0 for each of seven PLANs: **21/21 declared artifacts** exist and are substantive. Source inspection then checked their actual callers and data contracts. + +| Plan | Declared artifacts | Implementation/wiring evidence | Status | +|---|---|---|---| +| 01-01 | fidelity.py; fidelity_receipts.py; scenarios.json | CLI dispatches stage/identify/import/validate; shared validators consume supplied protocol and real byte inventories | VERIFIED | +| 01-02 | fidelity_review.py; fidelity_viewer/viewer.mjs; fidelity-viewer.test.mjs | Validated receipt export → review.json/local media → fetch → controller/renderer; actual pair absent | VERIFIED implementation; actual browser pending | +| 01-03 | capabilities.json; fidelity_ledger.py; docs/evidence/README.md | Validator checks tracked source/requirements/scenarios; canonical export supplies bundle and viewer current/history projection | VERIFIED | +| 01-04 | FidelityObservation.cs; managed observer test Program.cs; test_fidelity_observation.py | Outer Program continuation owns observer; actual raw/input/control/state hooks feed ordered JSONL; process tests feed receipt contract | VERIFIED bounded observer | +| 01-05 | fidelity_checkpoint.py; collect-fidelity-windows.ps1; windows-session.md | Preparation launcher calls assembler; actual files sealed/preflighted; PowerShell emits same versioned contract for later validated import | VERIFIED implementation; native execution pending | +| 01-06 | fidelity_capture.py; linux-session.md; collect-fidelity-linux.sh | Shell execs collector; selected package/observer/recorder argv and real-device preflight feed failure/capture collection and matrix | VERIFIED implementation; native physical capture pending | +| 01-07 | fidelity_acceptance.py; checkpoint-session.md; phase01-baseline.md | Explicit selected receipts/hashes + complete scenario audit + ten findings decide strict acceptance; baseline accurately leaves evidence open | VERIFIED implementation; final reconciliation pending | + +Paths above are the exact declared repository paths shown in each PLAN and fingerprint; no artifact is merely an unused placeholder. + +### Key Link Verification + +The owner heuristic returned 1/14 literal-path links and exit 1 on each PLAN. It searches literal target paths; Python module imports, C# class use, external schema contracts and prose names do not match. Those negative heuristic results are not treated as verified. Manual traces establish the implemented connections below; runtime-return links stay explicitly pending. + +| From → To | Actual connection | Status | +|---|---|---| +| fidelity.py → inventory baseline | stage_original → verify_inventory compares inventory.py-compatible file list with docs/original-manifest.json; no direct inventory.py import is needed | WIRED by shared inventory contract | +| fidelity_receipts.py → scenarios.json | CLI/capture pass loaded protocol to validate_scenario_contract/audit_scenarios; stable IDs and required obligations validated | WIRED | +| fidelity_review.py → fidelity_receipts.py | Imports and calls read_receipt, validate_receipt, contained_path, identify_file before export | WIRED | +| viewer.mjs → generated review/media | fetch('review.json') supplies per-side media/events to createPairController; controller enforces exclusive mute and independent times | WIRED; actual media/browser pending | +| capabilities.json → REQUIREMENTS.md | Validator extracts exact IDs and rejects incomplete coverage; all 33 IDs accounted for | WIRED | +| fidelity_ledger.py → viewer ledger | Canonical export/current/history projection copied during checkpoint assembly and rendered by renderCapabilities | WIRED | +| Program.cs → FidelityObservation.cs | Optional outer using owner passed through Run; real post-Step acceptsInput/state/control/raw SDL hooks call observer | WIRED | +| Observed JSONL → shared receipts | Versioned session/case/elapsed/tick payload validated through process interoperability and collector; synthetic scope preserved | WIRED contract; real route pending | +| prepare-fidelity-checkpoint.sh → fidelity_checkpoint.py | Explicit Python invocation consumes original inventory and completed sealed packages | WIRED | +| Windows collector → shared receipts | Emits schema-versioned raw receipts, exact content identities and failure states; documented agent-owned validation/import normalizes returned reviewed records | WIRED contract; actual returned data pending | +| fidelity_capture.py → Linux package/observer | Uses actual package executable/assets and --fidelity-* arguments after real display/audio preflight | WIRED; hardware execution pending | +| Linux receipts → review/acceptance | Collected diagnostics undergo shared validation/import and explicit current selection; real failed Linux receipt remains open | WIRED failure path; successful route pending | +| Returned Windows/Linux results → strict audit | audit reads current.json, validates contained selected receipts and receipt_sha256 binding, checks all 120 slots and named reviews | WIRED implementation; human return pending | +| phase01-baseline.md → capability ledger | Same open acceptance/current scope retained; documented reconciliation updates receipt-bound current/history after return | WIRED present baseline; future reconciliation pending | + +### Data-Flow Trace (Level 4) + +| Rendered/accepted value | Actual source and flow | Finding | +|---|---|---| +| Capability navigation/current/history/discrepancies | capabilities.json → validate/export → sealed protocol/capability-ledger.json → review.json → renderCapabilities | FLOWING: real maintained evidence; unimplemented and missing scopes remain visible | +| Paired video/audio/event times | Actual imported receipt artifacts/hashes → _side/_events export → review.json → media/controller | Implementation wired; current source is explicitly missing, not synthetic original footage | +| Observer input/state/elapsed | Actual SDL/control/post-Step data → retained observer → bounded JSONL → collector/receipt validation | FLOWING in bounded regressions; current complete physical capture unavailable | +| Native acceptance totals | Explicit selected actual receipt files + content identities → audit_scenarios + CHECKS → strict report | FLOWING: actual failed diagnostic yields 0/120, errors [], human_needed | + +Missing media is expected open evidence and is displayed as such; no hardcoded empty success path or invented original recording closes it. + +### Existing Behavioral Evidence Reviewed + +This completion pass did not rerun tests or launch services. Commands/results below are from retained execution receipts/logs, not SUMMARY assertions; fresh owner queries covered artifact presence, story validity and decision coverage. + +| Evidence | Recorded invocation/result | Limit | +|---|---|---| +| Integrated local suite | artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json and .log: scripts/test.sh, exit 0, 782.049626s; 556 Python (180 fidelity), 27 Node, 23 managed observer, 2 HUD, 51 managed entry-point invocations, 36 rendered GPU receipts, zero Vulkan errors, 539 originals | Before later tooling-only review fixes; dummy audio/headless checks are not physical/native baseline capture | +| Final tooling regression | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/python-fidelity-final.log: 191 tests, 43.355s, OK | Includes final copy-state artifact-root fix; no new runtime change or full GPU rerun claimed | +| Media controller | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/node-viewer-direct.log: 27 pass, 0 fail/skipped; named independent seek/drift, exclusive mute, rejected play, buffering, decode and full-tail assertions inspected | Media doubles exercise controller transitions, not actual browser decoding/audibility | +| Preservation | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/original-preservation.log: 539 unchanged originals | Byte preservation at check time; final P1 session conduct still needs disposition | +| Readiness | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/readiness-final.json plus verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json: 11,001 members, materials_ready true, human_needed | Sealed runtime provenance retained as 446930d dirty true / diff 90cef956…; later tooling revision does not relabel it | +| Strict acceptance | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/acceptance-final.json: require-complete exit 1, errors [], accepted 0/120, all ten findings pending | Expected open evidence; no malformed acceptance input or observed code failure | + +No phase-declared shell probe requiring a separate new execution was identified; the phase relies on the retained local CLI/test/preflight evidence. No full suite was repeated in this completion pass. + +### Requirements Coverage + +All four accountable requirement IDs are declared across the seven PLANs; no Phase 1 requirement is orphaned. Pending is retained in REQUIREMENTS.md. + +| Requirement | Source PLANs | Evidence and remaining dependency | Disposition | +|---|---|---|---| +| EVID-01 | 01,05,06,07 | 539 unchanged originals; bounded isolated staging, canonical inventory and pre/post checks implemented. Final actual session preservation/P1 remains pending | Pending — current preservation verified; final human disposition required | +| EVID-02 | 01,02,04,05,07 | Original-DxWnd collector/protocol/identity/review tooling ready; 0/40 actual original obligations and A1/original-boundary review open | Pending — NEEDS HUMAN | +| EVID-03 | 02,03,07 | All 33 full-game requirements represented in 25 capabilities/six groups; source/implementation/platform/history/discrepancy/open acceptance traceable. Returned-evidence reconciliation and P3 remain open | Pending — ledger implementation verified; final human/reconciliation dependency | +| EVID-04 | 01,02,04,05,06,07 | Native collectors, observer and exact package binding implemented; failed Linux physical preflight retained, no accepted native route; 0/80 accepted | Pending — NEEDS HUMAN | + +### Decision Coverage + +Owner query: **16/16** trackable CONTEXT decisions honored, not_honored []. “All trackable CONTEXT.md decisions are honored by shipped artifacts.” Advisory gate only; it does not change acceptance. + +### Test Quality and Anti-Patterns + +Active tests assert concrete identity bytes, rejection behavior, monotonic ownership/state, media-controller transitions and acceptance classification. Test-generated metadata/media are explicitly synthetic fixtures: they verify validators/controller behavior and are never original/native fidelity oracles. The complete-metadata positive matrix test cannot establish actual physical execution; strict real matrix stays 0/120. + +The targeted completion scan found no unreferenced TBD/FIXME/XXX or disabled requirement-test markers in the fidelity source/tests/scripts/observer scope; the prior completed 40-file debt/skip scan is retained. Expected empty initial review and false human-review fields preserve missing evidence. They are not stubs claiming completion. No new blocking anti-pattern was established. + +Existing gates remain recorded: security 22/22 mitigated, zero open; validation automation complete with manual checks open; independent review verification closes all five historical findings after 02d182f. UI review was explicitly disabled for this phase by the recorded gate configuration; TDD is inactive. These gates were not reopened. Broad tooling feedback 43.355s exceeds its 30s quick target (WARNING), with no effect on native acceptance. + +### Human Verification Required + +**Ten named findings remain pending.** Collect, observe and return one complete local result tree following docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md and its Windows/Linux subguides. The integration agent owns evidence-backed normalization, reviewed-copy creation, hash validation, import, current selection, ledger reconciliation and final strict audit after return. Raw receipts remain immutable. Positive human findings must never be generated automatically. + +#### 1. A1 — Capture and observe the isolated original through the selected DxWnd setup + +**Test:** A1 — Capture and observe the isolated original through the selected DxWnd setup using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** Complete 40 original-Windows-DxWnd obligations; observe moving game imagery and intelligible game audio, retaining actual executable/profile/copy inventories and wrapper/configuration limitations. +**Why human:** Original execution and audiovisual truth are unobserved; the backstop abstains with insufficient_spec. + +#### 2. A2 — Exercise actual paired recordings in the identified browser + +**Test:** A2 — Exercise actual paired recordings in the identified browser using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** Both real recordings decode, play at actual speed, seek to their own observed events, preserve full tails and switch exclusive audio without concealing elapsed time. +**Why human:** Controller tests use media doubles; they cannot establish real codec/browser/physical-audio behavior. Backstop: insufficient_spec. + +#### 3. EVID-02-unclassified — Review original capture boundaries and limitations + +**Test:** EVID-02-unclassified — Review original capture boundaries and limitations using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** Document observed original/DxWnd launch, crop, aspect, timing, recording boundaries and retained/fresh lifetimes for the actual reference captures. +**Why human:** This flagged assumption cannot be inferred from prepared settings or synthetic metadata. + +#### 4. EVID-04-unclassified — Collect and inspect both native platform routes + +**Test:** EVID-04-unclassified — Collect and inspect both native platform routes using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** Complete 40 native Windows and 40 native Linux obligations with actual OS/GPU/driver/Vulkan/SDL/source/package/resource identity and observed route/input/audio continuity. +**Why human:** Windows is cross-published only; current Linux TTY/auto_null preflight cannot capture native physical gameplay. + +#### 5. P1 — Resolve the original-preservation prohibition explicitly + +**Test:** P1 — Resolve the original-preservation prohibition explicitly using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** Confirm authoritative originals were never executed or changed; compare all 539 recorded hashes and generated-copy pre/retained/post inventories after the session. +**Why human:** Descriptor-less unresolved prohibition requires explicit disposition; current preserved hashes do not prove future session conduct. + +#### 6. P2 — Resolve the honest-comparison prohibition explicitly + +**Test:** P2 — Resolve the honest-comparison prohibition explicitly using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** Confirm genuine original media, no retiming or concealed drift, no mixed simultaneous soundtracks, and visible review gain/derivation provenance. +**Why human:** Unverified-prohibition — human review recommended; genuine playback and perceived audiovisual comparison require observation. + +#### 7. P3 — Resolve the history/full-scope/native-transparency prohibition explicitly + +**Test:** P3 — Resolve the history/full-scope/native-transparency prohibition explicitly using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** Confirm all 33 requirements and unimplemented content stay visible; conflicting/superseded evidence and native/Wine/component/cross-publish distinctions are preserved after reconciliation. +**Why human:** Unverified-prohibition — human review recommended; final returned-evidence reconciliation requires explicit judgment. + +#### 8. browser — Review the complete local comparison interface + +**Test:** browser — Review the complete local comparison interface using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** With real captures, verify readable independent clocks/drift, keyboard controls, raw unobstructed default views, optional annotations/differences and visible loading/error/tail states. +**Why human:** No actual browser visual/usability/codec review has been performed. + +#### 9. paired_review — Compare all corresponding actual recordings and record discrepancies + +**Test:** paired_review — Compare all corresponding actual recordings and record discrepancies using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** Review matched events, imagery and sound across the required cases, retaining raw drift and justified system-specific observations without invented tolerances. +**Why human:** No corresponding original/native pair or completed visual/audible comparison exists. + +#### 10. physical_input — Exercise visible native gameplay and actual audible devices + +**Test:** physical_input — Exercise visible native gameplay and actual audible devices using the combined-session guide. +**Expected:** On Linux and Windows use physical supported inputs through lab → VR04 → lab → outside, natural/skipped and fresh/retained cases, held input, banked jumps, landing and idle; confirm real display/audio output. +**Why human:** Injected/headless/GPU/dummy-audio fixtures prove narrower behavior and cannot satisfy physical-input or audibility acceptance. + +### Acceptance Conclusion + +Autonomous preparation is complete; the promised real comparison outcome remains human_needed. No implementation BLOCKER was established in this bounded completion. The observable absence of original/native accepted captures is a documented human/external evidence dependency, explicitly kept open by the roadmap contract, not silently passed. + +A1/A2 are **unverified non-inferable checks** (`insufficient_spec`); P1/P2/P3 are **unverified-prohibition — human review recommended**, with no automatic resolution. No later phase specifically replaces Phase 1 capture/review obligations, so none are deferred. No phase completion, advancement, commit or push was performed. + +The fingerprint was produced by the owner CLI `query verification.fingerprint` over the listed actual source/test/document/evidence inputs; its returned fields are copied verbatim. Planning PLAN/SUMMARY coverage was added by the owner. SUMMARYs supply intended interfaces, not proof of behavior. + +--- + +_Verified: 2026-11-14T05:34:19Z_ +_Verifier: gsd-verifier_ + diff --git a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md index 9fa696b..3dc0c61 100644 --- a/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md +++ b/.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/HANDOFF.md @@ -1,10 +1,12 @@ + + --- context: phase phase: 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline plan: "07" task: 3 total_tasks: 3 -status: paused +status: consumed last_updated: "2026-11-13T22:26:46.798618+00:00" --- diff --git a/docs/compatibility.md b/docs/compatibility.md index e5145d1..ff2a343 100644 --- a/docs/compatibility.md +++ b/docs/compatibility.md @@ -1,5 +1,16 @@ # Compatibility and validation +## Phase 1 verification — human session pending + +Final owner-validated verification is `human_needed`:29/42 truths verified and13 +uncertain pending actual observations. Ten named checks are saved in +`.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-UAT.md`. Autonomous materials, +review fixes, security and automation coverage are complete. Actual acceptance +remains0/120 OPEN; all EVID requirements stay Pending and Phase2 is unadvanced. +The combined session guide is `docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md`; the local +checkpoint is `dist/fidelity/phase01`. Resume human verification with +`$gsd-verify-work 1`. No new build/test or gameplay claim accompanies this report. + ## Final phase 1 review closure All five review findings are independently verified fixed. The final copy-state diff --git a/docs/decisions.md b/docs/decisions.md index 5770a7d..3069f65 100644 --- a/docs/decisions.md +++ b/docs/decisions.md @@ -1,5 +1,16 @@ # Decisions +## Phase 1 verification — human session pending + +Final owner-validated verification is `human_needed`:29/42 truths verified and13 +uncertain pending actual observations. Ten named checks are saved in +`.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-UAT.md`. Autonomous materials, +review fixes, security and automation coverage are complete. Actual acceptance +remains0/120 OPEN; all EVID requirements stay Pending and Phase2 is unadvanced. +The combined session guide is `docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md`; the local +checkpoint is `dist/fidelity/phase01`. Resume human verification with +`$gsd-verify-work 1`. No new build/test or gameplay claim accompanies this report. + ## Final phase 1 review closure All five review findings are independently verified fixed. The final copy-state diff --git a/docs/progress.md b/docs/progress.md index 8960b2b..0944685 100644 --- a/docs/progress.md +++ b/docs/progress.md @@ -1,5 +1,16 @@ # Progress — 2026-11-07 +## Phase 1 verification — human session pending + +Final owner-validated verification is `human_needed`:29/42 truths verified and13 +uncertain pending actual observations. Ten named checks are saved in +`.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-UAT.md`. Autonomous materials, +review fixes, security and automation coverage are complete. Actual acceptance +remains0/120 OPEN; all EVID requirements stay Pending and Phase2 is unadvanced. +The combined session guide is `docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md`; the local +checkpoint is `dist/fidelity/phase01`. Resume human verification with +`$gsd-verify-work 1`. No new build/test or gameplay claim accompanies this report. + ## Final phase 1 review closure All five review findings are independently verified fixed. The final copy-state diff --git a/docs/tasks.md b/docs/tasks.md index 53111ef..2cc115a 100644 --- a/docs/tasks.md +++ b/docs/tasks.md @@ -1,5 +1,16 @@ # Tasks +## Phase 1 verification — human session pending + +Final owner-validated verification is `human_needed`:29/42 truths verified and13 +uncertain pending actual observations. Ten named checks are saved in +`.planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-UAT.md`. Autonomous materials, +review fixes, security and automation coverage are complete. Actual acceptance +remains0/120 OPEN; all EVID requirements stay Pending and Phase2 is unadvanced. +The combined session guide is `docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md`; the local +checkpoint is `dist/fidelity/phase01`. Resume human verification with +`$gsd-verify-work 1`. No new build/test or gameplay claim accompanies this report. + ## Final phase 1 review closure All five review findings are independently verified fixed. The final copy-state