--- phase: 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline fixed_at: 2026-11-13T22:09:37Z review_path: .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW.md iteration: 1 findings_in_scope: 5 fixed: 5 skipped: 0 status: all_fixed --- # Phase 01: Code Review Fix Report All five confirmed findings were fixed. Their logic changes require independent human/reviewer verification; automated results below establish the stated tooling contracts, never original/native gameplay acceptance. No runtime/gameplay source, original file, package bytes, review disposition, or phase state was changed. | Finding | Status | Commit | Applied fix and regression | |---|---|---|---| | CR-01 | fixed: requires human verification | `5569bc2` | Carry the actual selected receipt path into digest review. Two different sibling JSON files without a sidecar prove that only the selected file's digest satisfies the human finding; absent/unrelated digests leave findings pending. | | CR-02 | fixed: requires human verification | `bda35e5` | Supply the complete checkpoint original file inventory, recompute its digest, and bind `identity.executable.original_member` plus size/header/hash to the exact pristine member. Original pre/post/package/resources require full baseline file records and digest. Positive original fixtures retain actual member/executable hashes; wrong executable/member and altered inventory records fail. Writable-copy post changes are separately identified and remain allowed. | | CR-03 | fixed: requires human verification | `6e5ee0b` | Bind both lifetimes to the validated named `identity.copy_pre` record; retained lifetimes also require `identity.retained_copy`. Unknown hashes and hashes of launcher/package/other state records fail. Fixtures now retain distinct actual copy-state files. | | WR-01 | fixed: requires human verification | `548c97a` | Assemble the existing validated ledger projection before review export, seal it at `protocol/capability-ledger.json`, and compare viewer current/history against it during readiness. Actual preparation-to-bundled-renderer regression retains the named current and superseded startup records; a sealed viewer missing history is rejected. | | WR-02 | fixed: requires human verification | `2608517` | Recover missing `run.json` only as aborted from the retained incomplete record. Preserve the raw initial bytes as an importable `recovery-initial.json` diagnostic artifact, retain session/start identity, remove initial placeholder end clocks, and reject captured promotion or launch-aligned events. Shared validation/import permits this open aborted record with absent end clocks. | WR-01 has one additional positive regression commit, `a821754`, proving readiness on a standalone copied checkpoint with no source Git checkout. No fix was skipped or rolled back. Five finding commits plus this verification commit were made. Modified source: `tools/recon/fidelity_acceptance.py`, `fidelity_receipts.py`, `fidelity_checkpoint.py`, and `scripts/collect-fidelity-windows.ps1`. Tests: `tests/test_fidelity_acceptance.py`, `test_fidelity_scenarios.py`, `test_fidelity_checkpoint.py`, and `fidelity-windows.Tests.ps1`. Field contracts: `docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md` and `windows-session.md`. No new source file or dependency was required. ## Verification All gates ran locally in the **main checkout**. The primary explicitly authorized a temporary `workflow.use_worktrees=false` override. Its original absent setting was restored without staging or committing it; the unused clean worktree was removed before edits. Unrelated untracked `tools.yaml` remains unchanged. Normal Git hooks ran for every commit. The WR-01 refinement was folded into its commit before the primary's no-rebase steering arrived; subsequent history is preserved. Logs are retained under ignored `artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/`: - `python-fidelity.log`: all 189 fidelity regressions passed in 40.072 seconds. Initial sandbox execution hit eight loopback-socket permission errors; the successful scoped-escalation run permits only the local tests' necessary host operations. These were environment errors, not accepted failed tests. - `acceptance-final.log`: 29 acceptance tests passed after the final standalone transfer regression was added. This includes the refined readiness path; these tests overlap the 189-test run and are not added to its count. - `node-viewer-direct.log`: 27 actual Node behavior tests passed. On this host `node --test` reports an aggregate one-file result; direct execution supplied the explicit 27-test count. The preparation test also rendered the real bundled model with the bundled renderer and a DOM double, without claiming browser playback evidence. - `powershell.log`: 18 package-free synthetic tooling checks passed under cached Linux-hosted PowerShell. This is not native Windows execution evidence. - `recovered-import.log`: the actual incomplete-only PowerShell output passed shared validation and atomic import; accepted is false. Raw fixture output and imported bytes are retained in separate `test-windows-results/` and `test-recovered-imports/` namespaces. - `original-preservation.log`: all 539 original files unchanged. The same inventory command passed after assembly as well; preparation independently checked the original inventory before and after copying. - Python parse checks and `git diff --check` passed. The prior 13-minute full managed/GPU suite was not repeated because these changes touch tooling and evidence contracts only. ## Fresh immutable checkpoint The final checkpoint was assembled **once**, using unchanged existing `artifacts/fidelity/01-05-packages/{linux-x64,win-x64}` bytes. The prior tree was preserved at `dist/fidelity/phase01-pre-review-48100025`; the documented current path remains `dist/fidelity/phase01`. No sealed member was patched after assembly. Mutable results contain a fresh import of the existing failed Linux preflight receipt and the unchanged pending human-review controls; no captured evidence was invented. The former assembly remains historical evidence. | Item | Identity/result | |---|---| | Current checkpoint | `dist/fidelity/phase01` | | Immutable members | 11001 | | READY SHA-256 | `7ceebcb3a22549a59bb9f7032c5c686b4ca4d32cf7b6a7d934e12e37f05e7aba` | | Manifest SHA-256 | `a4da759bb264d63b716a931ae3b16a410baf01e36a7b2696ae8ed5649f77f7a9` | | Tool commit | `a821754b6755151a0e33e4ac5065c8efd252b2e6` | | Tool working-tree provenance | Tracked diff empty; dirty true solely from preserved untracked `tools.yaml`, identified by the manifest | | Sealed runtime source | `446930d2a30d6d616c60ac5e59e4169a840bea09`, dirty true | | Runtime publish diff | `90cef95669caece53fe2d2c4736cf2ac05ed27f5d25ca03ab572589686bcb73d` | | Linux package tree | `124cf271e4952f3822eec5c24358447fcffc9e9e1803aded8d96d4d4472dc5a3` | | Windows package tree | `335e5b75ec15c0fa904113d8b69d4f50e2cfa403f1f2f225353bd9e586322ef4` | | Startup viewer projection | Two current and two historical records retained | | Readiness | Exit 0, `materials_ready: true`, `acceptance: human_needed` | | Strict acceptance | Exit 1, 0/120, no structural errors, all ten human findings pending | `prepare-checkpoint.log`, `readiness.json`, `acceptance.json`, and `failed-linux-import.json` retain the actual results. The readiness and acceptance reports also reside under the current bundle's mutable `results/` directory. The ten pending findings remain A1, A2, EVID-02-unclassified, EVID-04-unclassified, P1, P2, P3, browser, paired_review, and physical_input. The host still lacks actual original/native Windows capture access and a usable Linux display/audio session. Independent re-review and the primary's remaining security/coverage gates precede any combined capture request. This report is intentionally uncommitted for the primary workflow to review and commit. No push, package upload, original execution, or original write occurred. ## Final artifact-boundary refinement CR-03 independent re-review caught pathless hash-only named records. RED48fca0d reproduces fresh/retained missing-file, wrong-size and hash-only cases; GREEN02d182f validates actual named files inside scenario observation with an explicit root. All191 fidelity tests pass in43.355s; focused26 scenario/23 capture/29 acceptance checks pass. Independent reviewer confirms allfive findings fixed; security auditor closes22/22 planned threats. The earlier11001-file bundle is retained locally; current dist/fidelity/phase01 is freshly assembled from corrected source with original runtime package identities unchanged.