# Supplied jn-engine assessment 2026-11-03. User requested review of `../../../SURVEY-for-Rockman.md` and `../../../jn-engine-master/`. The survey was read in full; its generated claims were checked against supplied source/artifacts and our existing evidence. Read-only review of that tree; no friend code, legacy executables, deployment, network services or Ghidra scripts executed. GamePort source baseline: d6ca417; documentation HEAD on entry: c0acf58. No gameplay changes or new runtime claim. ## Conclusion **Useful research and validation material, especially the saved decompiler bodies and original capture tooling. It is not a more complete faithful gameplay implementation to substitute for this port.** Keep C#/.NET10, SDL3 and Vulkan. Use their class/address index to accelerate REA investigations; independently check each imported interpretation. Their C/SDL2/OpenGL gameplay intentionally contains approximations which our recent recovered gadget slices already exceed. Detailed independent reviews: [gameplay](jn-engine-gameplay.md), [capture/tooling](jn-engine-capture.md). A ready-to-share [evidence request](jn-engine-capture-request.md) records the most valuable additional material; nothing has been sent externally. ## Identity and corpus checks Local SHA-256 recomputation versus `J:docs/binaries.sha256`: | Binary | Our original | Friend's declared original | Consequence | |---|---|---|---| | Neutron.exe | 1,019,904 bytes; `f5281076e1a2492f2d61f87aae3f4544b6d0f535ebe33f9fbb6f78710fe1aea8` | Identical declared size/hash | EXE addresses can be cross-indexed | | OMT2.dll | 1,343,488 bytes; `3ec41ead011adf56387a6dbd4580e5b5a9721b5f8020c8a56420f42824354943` | 1,339,392 bytes; `a94f13e148bff790aab556d0381055df57f2ff4f9abc5947c25847c7370b0fea` | Reconcile DLL build before reusing DLL addresses or treating captures as our exact engine version | Friend originals are not included, so the second column is a direct measurement and the third a supplied manifest declaration. A DLL difference does not make their measurements invalid; it limits their automatic applicability. Case-insensitive filename pairing and SHA-256 comparison establish **all 254 Original/ASE, 126 Original/png and 35 Original/gam files are byte-identical to their supplied counterparts**. Friend directories contain two additional ASEs (`bigbotstop.ase`, `sporkystop.ase`) and thirty additional PNGs. Do not merge these extras into our authoritative asset set. The survey's asset-count explanation is stale; our earlier 128 PNG count includes two root font PNGs outside Original/png. Our full original manifest verifies all539 files unchanged after this review. ## Evidence value and reuse order Here `J:` means `../../../jn-engine-master/`, relative to this report. | Material | Verified scope | Recommended use | |---|---|---| | Class ledger and reports | 208 ledger rows, all `spec`: 181 Medium/27 Low; reports present | Naming/address/dependency index, not a completion percentage | | Jimmy target6 decompiler output | Saved helper bodies including 428D50, 427FF0, 429D00, 426A70; generic signatures have artifacts | First gameplay reuse: compare Grappler/Rocketship recovery with REA and guarded EXE bytes | | C3DAnimated report/dispatch | Completion and selection timing rules, including repeated end callbacks | Candidate for replacing limited animation ownership after independent verification | | GAM schema, class IDs, SCENE/KITTY transition table | Source/data research over shared level corpus; several effects deferred | Expand campaign coverage checklist and identify missing owners/callers | | Linkage oracles | 16 substantive Python scripts plus template, building their C dumpers | Adapt selected expected-value functions/corpus cases to a GamePort adapter; not drop-in original-runtime tests | | DDraw proxy and OMTC protocol | Real draw/state/texture capture implementation; derived Level1 fixtures supplied | Calibrate selected Vulkan states after matching binary/version and matrix conventions | | Ghidra scripts and offered database | Scripts included; analysed project absent | Apply reviewed naming/function-boundary ideas to a copied project through our REA workflow | | Gameplay state tap / deterministic original replay | Proposed in survey; not implemented/included | Request a minimal phase-aware trace before building a replay consumer | **Immediate recovery lead:** `J:docs/decomp/evidence/c3djimmy_target6.md:2556` contains Jimmy429D00, previously unidentified by our default analysis. Its header and `J:tools/ghidra/CreateFunctions.java` explain how explicit boundaries were created. This can unblock investigation, but forced `__thiscall`, `unaff_retaddr` and uninitialized aliases prevent treating the output as a finished algorithm or ABI. Maintain REA Evidence and byte checks when continuing. ## Corrections before adoption - Movement is explicitly tuned: instant tank movement, jump650 and gravity1600. This is not evidence to replace our recovered550/800 behavior. - Their native gadget list includes Jetpack and omits Baseball; Shrink Ray uses raw6, conflicting with our recovered item6/raw6 Baseball. Invisible activation, Bubble placement, Grappler pull, Scooter mounting and Baseball lifetime also contain native design/tunings. Use class evidence, not these replacement rules. - Jimmy field maps mix complete-object and game-interface bases. Our established interface is complete+C0. Movement mode is complete+7C4/interface+704; jump state complete+7E8/interface+728; shadow distance complete+86C/interface+7AC. The survey mixes these bases in its proposed tap list. Its corrected shadow interpretation is also not propagated to `J:docs/decomp/C3DPlayer.md`. - Capture fixtures are derived evidence, not an included raw stream: 390 files, 13,512,573 bytes; anchor8881 has3523 draws/342 textures at640x480. No `.omtc` or named original reference screenshot is present. The “oracle diff” checks fixture structure/counts/configuration, not pixels or gameplay trajectories. - No-fog/vertex-alpha/projection observations are capture-specific. Verify state and matrix storage before changing global rendering policies. - The survey compared older builds; its “other seven gadgets” and “no vehicles” coverage statements do not describe current GamePort recovery/integration. - No licence file was found in the supplied tree. Record the offered written permission or permissive licence before directly importing friend code/scripts. Field/loop cross-checks: [movement checkpoint](../analysis/movement-checkpoint.md), [Bubble pointer/slot contracts](../gameplay/bubble-motion.md), [loop ownership](../checkpoint/loop-motion.md). Detailed citations for the C runtime differences and capture limits are in the two independent reviews. ## Concrete next steps and remaining questions 1. For the next gadget slice, use the saved429D00/426A70 bodies and Rocketship class report to guide a bounded REA recovery. Resolve pointer bases, callers, ownership and body dependencies before implementation; do not port prototype gadget movement. 2. Request the analysed Ghidra database, raw OMTC with matching screenshots and exact capture DLL hashes. Their existing Level1 fixtures are useful now, but raw data is needed to reproduce the claimed renderer observations independently. 3. Start the proposed original-state instrumentation with VR04 movement/jetpack, then lab→tutorial→lab→outside including Carl/RETURN. Require game-update phases, initial state and stable actor identity before planning replay tooling. 4. Later adapt one camera oracle and animation-completion cases, explicitly separating recovered-model consistency from original-runtime comparison. Open: capture DLL version/availability; raw evidence and analysed project; corrected/typed field maps and function signatures; original simulation cadence; renderer parity; actual state-tap feasibility; final-level/credits behavior; code reuse permission. None is silently resolved by this source intake. Validation this turn: source/artifact review, exact binary/corpus hashes, ledger counts and original-manifest verification. No new build, port regression run, original execution or native Windows validation was needed or claimed.