Files

9.2 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Phase 01 source audit

Planned 2026-11-12. COVERED means executable tasks exist, not that original/native acceptance has passed. All four source types are audited; no required source item is dropped. Existing instructions, current original inventory and all D-01–D-16 remain binding.

Source ID Required outcome Plans Status
GOAL G1 Reproduce identified original/port scenarios and exact native proof 01–07 COVERED
GOAL SC1 Original inventory and isolated generated execution 01,05–07 COVERED
GOAL SC2 Actual original visual/audio/input/event reference, or open access 01,02,05,07 COVERED
GOAL SC3 Full-game evidence→implementation→platform→discrepancy→acceptance 03,07 COVERED
GOAL SC4 Same native Linux/Windows baseline with exact identity 04–07 COVERED
REQ EVID-01 Every original unchanged; generated output separate 01,05–07 COVERED
REQ EVID-02 Reproducible actual original reference and open limitations 01,02,04,05,07 COVERED
REQ EVID-03 Maintained full-game capability coverage ledger 02,03,07 COVERED
REQ EVID-04 Current native Linux/Windows baseline, separately classified 01,02,04–07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-01 Continuous route plus focused moments 01,04,06,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-02 Equal natural/skipped runs 01,04,06,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-03 Equal fresh/retained runs and correct lifetimes 01,04,06,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-04 Ordinary and edge input/bank/landing/idle 01,04,06,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-05 Paired playback and corresponding artifacts 02,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-06 Unobstructed captures; optional overlays 02,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-07 Event alignment at actual speed; exposed drift 02,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-08 Exclusive corresponding audio; visible review gain 02,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-09 Capability navigation with requirement/source/receipt links 03,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-10 Works/verified/differences/acceptance lead each capability 03,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-11 Current applicability first, exact superseded history 03,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-12 Player-impact order without closing missing evidence 03,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-13 User Windows availability, actual execution pending 01,05,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-14 One identified local bundle/collector per checkpoint 05,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-15 Generated original through identified DxWnd 01,05,07 COVERED
CONTEXT D-16 All materials before one combined human session 05–07 COVERED
RESEARCH R1 Stdlib tools, no dependency modernization/install All COVERED
RESEARCH R2 Stage/copy/source identity, fresh allocation, atomic failure 01,05 COVERED
RESEARCH R3 Actual source/package/executable/resource/media hashes 01,05–07 COVERED
RESEARCH R4 Typed evidence, failed/incomplete/missing remains open 01,03,05–07 COVERED
RESEARCH R5 Eight explicit matrix cells, continuous and focused obligations 01,04–07 COVERED
RESEARCH R6 Passive accepted-input/control/scene observation across continuations 04 COVERED
RESEARCH R7 External original recording; manual observed markers/uncertainty 05,07 COVERED
RESEARCH R8 Raw MKV/verified preview, derivation/time/crop metadata 02,05–07 COVERED
RESEARCH R9 Paired clocks/drift, seeking/range, exclusive audio/error/tail states 02,07 COVERED
RESEARCH R10 Full 33-requirement ledger and checkpoint-row reconciliation 03 COVERED
RESEARCH R11 Content/scope/platform current applicability and explicit history 03,07 COVERED
RESEARCH R12 Actual dependency/version/profile/media preflight and local transfer 05,07 COVERED
RESEARCH R13 Real native Linux/Windows/physical audio/input and actual original 05–07 COVERED; execution remains a dependency
RESEARCH R14 Bounded input, path/symlink safety, no receipt commands, safe viewer All relevant tools COVERED
RESEARCH R15 Meaningful negative tests, nonempty discovery, no fake native pass All COVERED
RESEARCH R16 Preserve movement/body/TSK/bank/admission; no source investigation needed 01,04,06,07 COVERED
RESEARCH R17 Actual browser/codec and original capture hypotheses A1/A2 02,05,07 COVERED with human backstops
RESEARCH R18 Local full suite, original verification and durable status before transition 07 COVERED

No deferred ideas were supplied. Later-phase gameplay expansion is excluded by phase ownership, not omitted from this phase's required evidence ledger. The RESEARCH initial-real-pair recommendation is satisfied by eventual actual pairing in 07; its synthetic plumbing allowance enables earlier 01/02 without claiming parity or blocking preparation.

Spec-less edge report: no silent drop

Source: actual deterministic /tmp/gameport-edge-coverage.json, 9 rows. Seven classified rows receive explicit criteria in must_haves.truths; both unclassified rows remain unresolved flagged assumptions in 01-07. No auto-dismissal. 9 surfaced = 7 explicit authored + 2 flagged unresolved.

Requirement Category Disposition / exact boundary Plan/task
EVID-01 adjacency Reject equal/nested/aliased source/output; allow distinct sibling prefixes 01-01-01
EVID-01 empty Empty/missing inventory invalid; one-file round-trip valid 01-01-01
EVID-01 ordering Canonical relative path order; reject normalized identity collisions 01-01-01
EVID-01 concurrency Exclusive allocation, atomic publish, interrupted incomplete, duplicate import rules 01-01-01
EVID-02 unclassified Unresolved flagged assumption; manual original/DxWnd capture review 01-07-02
EVID-03 adjacency Identical duplicate receipt idempotent, conflicting bytes/history rejected 01-03-01
EVID-03 empty Empty ledger invalid; single capability renderable 01-03-01
EVID-03 ordering Stable ID tie-breaks; explicit supersession, conflict/cycle checks 01-03-01/02
EVID-04 unclassified Unresolved flagged assumption; actual native route/input/audio review 01-07-02

Research A1/A2 backstop truths are separate from the two unclassified rows: backstops abstain to human_needed if unconfirmed and do not auto-resolve those rows.

Prohibition recall and precision

Stage 1 adversarial recall considered ten candidates per requirement:

Requirement Raw candidates
EVID-01 Original mutation, original in-place execution, changed baseline regeneration, empty tree, symlink escape, alias overlap, hash mismatch, partial copy, concurrent allocation, accidental original write
EVID-02 Synthetic parity, hidden retiming, mixed audio, wrapper as historical parity, black capture, silent capture, missing input, fake markers, swallowed abort, unsafe receipt command
EVID-03 Erased history, hidden unimplemented content, missing-proof completion, newest-date selection, duplicate conflict, empty ledger, lost requirements, impact ordering, dead links, injected labels
EVID-04 Wine as native, cross-publish as native, fixture as gameplay, absent Windows proof, fabricated audible pass, available PC as success, wrong package, stale resources, lost lifetime, zero tests

Stage 2 drops ordinary correctness/hygiene into edge tests and implementation review. Canon path traversal/injection/access control are referred to per-plan STRIDE/ASVS and secure-phase review, not minted as product prohibitions. Three merged bespoke project values survive: P1 authoritative preservation; P2 honest unretimed/unmixed/non-synthetic comparison; P3 historical/full-scope/native proof transparency. P1 maps EVID-01 to 01-01; P2 maps EVID-02 to 01-02; P3 maps EVID-03/EVID-04 to 01-03. They were projected through the installed probe-core.cjs projectProhibitions serializer and authored descriptor-less with status unresolved. No check_* descriptor or must-NOT truth was fabricated. They remain flagged-unverified for final judgment. 3 kept = 3 must_haves.prohibitions; 0 silently dropped.

Planning evidence and limits

Discovery level 1 is satisfied by current research/official documentation and inspected repository analogs; no new integration/dependency selection is introduced. Existing source paths were grounded with git ls-files. New artifacts are explicitly listed per plan. No prior verify commands/summaries exist; no new implementation/tests/fixtures ran during planning. UI gate supplied frontend=false/block=false; local paired viewer remains fully in scope. Assumption-delta supplied detected=false. Graph is disabled. API capability detector can false-trigger on local viewer/media terminology; COVERAGE.md records the reasoned no-external-integration declaration.

All seven plans have 2–3 tasks and first-task tracers, five execution waves, zero same-wave file overlap and unique T-01-01 through T-01-21 threats plus reserved T-01-SC. Security uses ASVS1 with high blocking. Full-suite durations remain to be measured; quick checks target under 30 seconds. Human verification is a single end-of-phase session, with strict actual acceptance dependencies preserved.