43 KiB
phase, verified, status, score, covered_files, covered_digest, behavior_unverified, overrides_applied, decision_coverage, non_inferable_checks, unverified_prohibitions, human_verification
| phase | verified | status | score | covered_files | covered_digest | behavior_unverified | overrides_applied | decision_coverage | non_inferable_checks | unverified_prohibitions | human_verification | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline | 2026-11-14T05:34:19Z | human_needed | 29/42 must-haves verified |
|
v4:sha256:70961b746a2cfc2cdb08a10750338dafb95fa17bd4ab0ecb4e3453c6c1075bcc | 0 | 0 |
|
|
|
|
Phase 1: Reproducible Fidelity Baseline Verification Report
Phase Goal: As a tester, I want to reproduce identified original/port comparison scenarios, so that I understand exactly what the current reconstruction proves on each native platform.
Verified: 2026-11-14T05:34:19Z
Status: human_needed
Re-verification: No existing VERIFICATION.md; completion of the interrupted initial verification after the MVP goal-format correction (febb4a9). No scope change or override.
User Flow Coverage
| Step | Expected | Evidence | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open the local checkpoint and inspect identities | Identified offline original copy, both port packages, complete agenda and viewer | Final readiness receipt: 11,001 immutable members; materials_ready true | VERIFIED for preparation |
| Reproduce isolated original scenarios | Moving imagery, intelligible audio, input/events and retained/fresh provenance from the actual selected DxWnd configuration | Collector/guide prepared; no returned original gameplay captures; 0/40 accepted | UNCERTAIN — WARNING; A1, EVID-02, P1 |
| Repeat matching native Linux/Windows routes | Same route/cases with physical input, real display/audio and exact runtime identities | Windows cross-publish only; real Linux preflight failed without selected X11/real audio; 0/80 accepted | UNCERTAIN — WARNING; EVID-04, physical_input |
| Inspect paired playback | Actual corresponding media with independent event times, exposed drift and exclusive audio | Controller is implemented/tested; prepared viewer contains no actual pair | UNCERTAIN — WARNING; A2, browser, paired_review, P2 |
| Trace what each capability proves | Source/implementation/platform/scope/discrepancy/remaining-acceptance links across the full game | 25 capabilities, six groups, all 33 requirements; current/history preserved | VERIFIED for traceability; P3 final judgment pending |
| Understand the reconstruction on each native platform | Actual identified original/native evidence plus honest discrepancies and unresolved limitations | Audit: errors [], 0/120 accepted; ten named human findings pending | UNCERTAIN — WARNING; user-story outcome remains open |
The MVP user flow is incomplete. No new technical runtime/test run was started to bypass it. The implementation evidence below records inspected code and already completed local verification; it does not constitute manual acceptance. Phase 1 is not passed and Phase 2 is not advanced by this report.
Goal Achievement
Observable Truths
Roadmap criteria are retained in full; PLAN truths add detail and do not reduce them. VERIFIED on a tooling truth certifies its bounded implementation, not original/native fidelity. UNCERTAIN items request human verification rather than asserting missing implementation. No accepted override exists.
| ID | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| SC1 | A reviewer can verify every original against the recorded inventory and run investigation/reference copies without altering the original installation. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | verify_inventory/staging and saved 539-file check prove current preservation; actual generated-copy reference execution and P1 disposition remain unobserved. |
| SC2 | A tester can reproduce identified whole-original reference scenarios from an isolated generated installation and inspect corresponding input/events, images and audio where applicable; unavailable execution keeps this criterion open. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Actual original-DxWnd captures absent; explicit access limitation leaves 40 obligations open (A1/EVID-02). |
| SC3 | A reviewer can trace every full-game capability from original evidence through current implementation, platform receipts, discrepancies and its remaining acceptance condition. | VERIFIED | Ledger validator/export/renderer connect 25 capabilities to all 33 requirements, source paths, implementation revisions, scoped platform records, differences and open acceptance. |
| SC4 | Testers can repeat the same baseline movement/route scenarios on native Linux and native Windows with exact revision identities; Wine/cross-publish receipts remain separately labeled and cannot close missing native execution. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | No accepted current native baseline capture on either platform: 40 Linux + 40 Windows obligations remain open (EVID-04/physical_input). |
| 01.1 | A reviewer can stage and identify a pristine generated original installation without altering any original byte (EVID-01, D-15). | VERIFIED | fidelity.py:stage calls stage_original; verify_inventory compares all recorded file identities before/after isolated copying. Saved original-preservation log verifies 539 unchanged originals. Actual DxWnd execution remains separately pending. |
| 01.2 | The protocol requires continuous lab → VR04 → lab → outside and focused dialogue-return, left/right banked-jump, landing and idle captures per D-01 and D-04. | VERIFIED | scenarios.json requires continuous lab → VR04 → lab → outside plus dialogue-return, left/right bank, landing/idle; validate_scenario_contract/audit_scenarios enforce obligations. |
| 01.3 | Natural/skipped dialogue and fresh/retained entry are equally required, independently identified dimensions per D-02 and D-03. | VERIFIED | Eight case IDs independently cross fresh/retained, natural/skipped and ordinary/held-input; scenario validator rejects collapsed dimensions. |
| 01.4 | Equal, nested, symlink-aliased and Windows case-aliased source/output paths fail before any staging write; sibling paths merely sharing a textual prefix remain distinct. | VERIFIED | separated_roots, symlink rejection and canonical path checks precede staging writes; session regressions cover equal/nested/case/symlink/prefix cases. |
| 01.5 | Empty/missing inventories fail; single-file fixtures round-trip, while changed, missing and added files invalidate identity. | VERIFIED | identify_tree rejects empty inventory; exact file-list comparison rejects changed/missing/added files; single-file round-trip regressions are active. |
| 01.6 | Manifest order is canonical relative POSIX path order; case-colliding identities fail instead of acquiring filesystem-dependent order. | VERIFIED | identify_tree sorts POSIX paths and rejects casefold collisions; canonical-order regression checks actual list/digest values. |
| 01.7 | Interrupted staging/import leaves an explicit incomplete diagnostic and no completed receipt; simultaneous same-session allocation has one winner, and duplicate receipt imports are idempotent only for byte-identical content. | VERIFIED | _reserve, exclusive writes, incomplete siblings and atomic publication implement allocation/import ownership. Named concurrency/interruption/duplicate regressions in test_fidelity_sessions.py pass in saved 191-test run. |
| 01.8 | Typed receipt validation retains failures and missing evidence as open acceptance; D-13 Windows availability is not a runtime receipt. | VERIFIED | validate_receipt/audit_scenarios separate failure, synthetic, component, Wine and native kinds. Current real failed Linux receipt remains OPEN; availability is no receipt. |
| 02.1 | A tester opens a local scenario with paired original/port playback and corresponding image, audio and input/event links per D-05. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Exporter/controller support paired validated receipts, but final review.json has no actual original/native pair. A1/A2/browser/paired_review remain human checks. |
| 02.2 | Raw captures are unobstructed by default; annotations and provenance-bound image differences are optional overlays per D-06. | VERIFIED | Controller defaults annotations/difference false; corresponding Node overlay/provenance regressions cover opt-in state. Actual visual unobstruction remains part of browser review. |
| 02.3 | Selecting an event seeks each recording to its own observed time; both play at actual speed with separate elapsed clocks, event drift and playback drift per D-07. | VERIFIED | Named Node event-selection/drift/readiness tests assert separate observed times, rate 1, independent elapsed clocks and exposed drift. This verifies controller behavior, not actual codec/browser playback. |
| 02.4 | The reviewer switches corresponding original/port audio with at most one source audible and visible review gain per D-08. | VERIFIED | Named exclusive-soundtrack/gain tests assert both muted before selecting one and labeled review-only gain. Physical audibility remains pending. |
| 02.5 | Missing, buffering, rejected-play, decoding and asymmetric-end states remain visible and preserve the full recording tails. | VERIFIED | Named rejected-play/buffering/decode/asymmetric-end tests assert paired pause, visible cause and resumable full longer tail. Real browser observation is still A2. |
| 03.1 | Reviewers browse movement, contacts, gadgets, progression, visuals and audio with requirement/source/scenario/platform links per D-09. | VERIFIED | GROUPS and ledger contain movement, contacts, gadgets, progression, visuals and audio; exported capability links include source/requirement/scenario/platform. |
| 03.2 | Each capability leads with working behavior, verified scope/platform, known differences and remaining acceptance per D-10. | VERIFIED | Capability rows carry working summary, verified scope, implementation revision, differences and open acceptance; renderer presents supplied facts. |
| 03.3 | Current applicable evidence precedes expandable explicitly superseded revision history per D-11; applicability uses content/scope/platform rather than newest date. | VERIFIED | Scope/content/platform applicability and explicit supersession retain current/history. Final reviewed fix verifies both projections survive bundle export; newest date is not acceptance. |
| 03.4 | Discrepancies order blocking/disruptive failures before subtler differences and missing verification per D-12; all missing evidence keeps acceptance open. | VERIFIED | IMPACTS orders blocking/disruptive/subtle/missing_verification; acceptance stays open. Strict current audit has no accepted runtime obligations. |
| 03.5 | All 33 full-game requirements have capability coverage even when unimplemented; an empty ledger fails and one capability remains renderable. | VERIFIED | Ledger covers 25 capabilities and all 33 requirements across six groups; validator rejects empty ledger, renderer supports a singleton. Full-game implementation is not claimed. |
| 03.6 | Equal receipt/content identities merge only when the record bytes match; conflicts remain explicit, and duplicate history rows never silently overwrite evidence. | VERIFIED | Canonical byte conflict checks prevent contradictory receipt/content deduplication and preserve history; ledger regression assertions cover conflicts. |
| 03.7 | Equal-priority entries have deterministic stable ID ordering; explicit supersession cycles and unresolved contradictory current claims fail validation. | VERIFIED | Stable ID sorting, supersession-cycle and contradictory-current validation are implemented and covered by active ledger regressions. |
| 04.1 | An optional passive observer records actual native port input/control/scene events across the continuous route per D-01, without changing gameplay or scene lifetime. | VERIFIED | Program.cs:18-30 owns one optional observer across outer Run continuations; post-Step calls at 1328-1333 use actual accepted input/state. Managed/process regressions cover observer wiring; no physical route acceptance inferred. |
| 04.2 | Natural/skipped and fresh/retained runs have distinct case identities, with one monotonic session across actual retained continuations per D-02 and D-03. | VERIFIED | One retained observer/monotonic session spans Run continuations; distinct case identity and simulation ticks are preserved. Existing observer tests exercise clock/order/continuation. |
| 04.3 | Held/neutral input, banked jump, landing and idle observations retain their real owner/tick/time per D-04; injected smoke fixtures stay separately classified. | VERIFIED | Actual raw SDL/input/state/control calls include owner/tick/time; smoke/injected paths are separately classified. Managed and process assertions check payload/receipt interoperability. |
| 04.4 | An output failure leaves the observation incomplete and visible rather than reporting acceptance or changing movement/state to finish the recording. | VERIFIED | Observer write failure emits an incomplete diagnostic without completing acceptance; standalone managed failure regressions exercise this path. |
| 05.1 | One complete local checkpoint bundle contains identified port packages, a verified generated original copy, scenarios, viewer and result collection per D-14. | VERIFIED | Final checkpoint receipt identifies 11,001 immutable members, both sealed packages, generated original seed, protocol, viewer and result collectors; readiness true. |
| 05.2 | The available Windows PC is treated as a pending execution environment per D-13; actual OS/GPU/driver/tool identities are collected during the session. | VERIFIED | Windows session guide/collector require actual OS/GPU/driver/tool observations; no native Windows receipt exists. Pending environment is explicitly distinguished from execution. |
| 05.3 | The original launches only from a generated copy through the user's identified DxWnd binary/exported profile, separately from native port receipts, per D-15. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Collector protects original-pristine, copies a writable run, retains selected DxWnd/profile and requires GUI launch. Actual user-selected DxWnd execution/configuration is unobserved; A1/P1 pending. |
| 05.4 | All original-reference and port materials are prepared before one combined session per D-16; preparation does not close EVID-02 or EVID-04. | VERIFIED | Readiness validates both package identities and complete 80-obligation Windows agenda; guide also requires 40 Linux obligations. ready() always reports human_needed. |
| 05.5 | Launcher preflight or recording failure produces an actionable local failure receipt without inventing successful capture or downloading dependencies. | VERIFIED | Collector/preflight failures retain diagnostic/open states. Actual Linux TTY/null-audio failure is retained; PowerShell recovery checks cover aborted incomplete collection without invented success. |
| 06.1 | An identified native Linux package yields actual input/event and audiovisual captures where execution is available; synthetic/headless replays remain distinct (EVID-04). | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Native Linux collector invokes identified package/observer and real recorder only after preflight. Current host has no selected real display/audio and produced failed preflight, with no gameplay capture. |
| 06.2 | Continuous route and focused captures cover all natural/skipped, fresh/retained and ordinary/edge cells per D-01–D-04, with missing executions explicitly open. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Matrix/scenario implementation requires all 40 Linux obligations and tracks missing cases, but no physical Linux route/focused capture is accepted. |
| 06.3 | Physical input/audio and real visible gameplay require actual native receipts/human review; dummy audio and window-only fixtures cannot complete acceptance. | VERIFIED | Preflight rejects dummy/null devices; native review requires real input/audibility/visibility. Strict audit cannot accept headless/synthetic fixtures. |
| 07.1 | One fully prepared combined session covers original-DxWnd and native Windows cases, local Linux review and real paired playback, per D-13–D-16. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Materials and one-session agenda are ready; the combined original/native/browser session has not occurred. |
| 07.2 | Every required original-reference and native Linux/Windows case has exact revision/package/resource/media and observation provenance; absent or failed cases keep EVID-02/EVID-04 open. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Strict audit reports 0/120 accepted, no structural errors and every missing obligation. Exact successful runtime/media provenance cannot yet be verified. |
| 07.3 | Paired review of actual original/port captures applies D-05–D-08 and publishes raw drift, discrepancies and audible/visible checks. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | No actual paired recordings or witnessed drift/audio/visual review returned; paired_review/P2 remain pending. |
| 07.4 | Current capabilities/history/discrepancies are reconciled to returned receipts per D-09–D-12, with full matrix completeness per D-01–D-04. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | Current baseline and ledger honestly retain missing evidence; returned-receipt reconciliation awaits actual collection and agent-owned normalization/import. |
| 07.5 | Actual original-DxWnd moving game imagery and intelligible audio are observed and reviewed with wrapper/config limitations recorded. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | UNCERTAIN — insufficient_spec: no observed original-DxWnd moving imagery/intelligible audio and wrapper review (A1); metadata fixtures cannot prove it. |
| 07.6 | Actual paired recordings decode, seek and switch exclusive audio in the identified local browser without concealing elapsed time. | UNCERTAIN — WARNING | UNCERTAIN — insufficient_spec: no actual identified-browser decode/seek/exclusive-audio observation (A2); Node media doubles cannot prove browser codecs or audibility. |
Score: 29/42 truths verified; 13 UNCERTAIN. Present-but-behavior-unverified invariants: 0. Existing behavioral regressions exercise the tooling transitions; the unverified items concern actual external execution, media, physical experience and final reconciliation. A1/A2 separately abstain with insufficient_spec.
Required Artifacts and Wiring Evidence
Owner query verify.artifacts independently returned exit 0 for each of seven PLANs: 21/21 declared artifacts exist and are substantive. Source inspection then checked their actual callers and data contracts.
| Plan | Declared artifacts | Implementation/wiring evidence | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 01-01 | fidelity.py; fidelity_receipts.py; scenarios.json | CLI dispatches stage/identify/import/validate; shared validators consume supplied protocol and real byte inventories | VERIFIED |
| 01-02 | fidelity_review.py; fidelity_viewer/viewer.mjs; fidelity-viewer.test.mjs | Validated receipt export → review.json/local media → fetch → controller/renderer; actual pair absent | VERIFIED implementation; actual browser pending |
| 01-03 | capabilities.json; fidelity_ledger.py; docs/evidence/README.md | Validator checks tracked source/requirements/scenarios; canonical export supplies bundle and viewer current/history projection | VERIFIED |
| 01-04 | FidelityObservation.cs; managed observer test Program.cs; test_fidelity_observation.py | Outer Program continuation owns observer; actual raw/input/control/state hooks feed ordered JSONL; process tests feed receipt contract | VERIFIED bounded observer |
| 01-05 | fidelity_checkpoint.py; collect-fidelity-windows.ps1; windows-session.md | Preparation launcher calls assembler; actual files sealed/preflighted; PowerShell emits same versioned contract for later validated import | VERIFIED implementation; native execution pending |
| 01-06 | fidelity_capture.py; linux-session.md; collect-fidelity-linux.sh | Shell execs collector; selected package/observer/recorder argv and real-device preflight feed failure/capture collection and matrix | VERIFIED implementation; native physical capture pending |
| 01-07 | fidelity_acceptance.py; checkpoint-session.md; phase01-baseline.md | Explicit selected receipts/hashes + complete scenario audit + ten findings decide strict acceptance; baseline accurately leaves evidence open | VERIFIED implementation; final reconciliation pending |
Paths above are the exact declared repository paths shown in each PLAN and fingerprint; no artifact is merely an unused placeholder.
Key Link Verification
The owner heuristic returned 1/14 literal-path links and exit 1 on each PLAN. It searches literal target paths; Python module imports, C# class use, external schema contracts and prose names do not match. Those negative heuristic results are not treated as verified. Manual traces establish the implemented connections below; runtime-return links stay explicitly pending.
| From → To | Actual connection | Status |
|---|---|---|
| fidelity.py → inventory baseline | stage_original → verify_inventory compares inventory.py-compatible file list with docs/original-manifest.json; no direct inventory.py import is needed | WIRED by shared inventory contract |
| fidelity_receipts.py → scenarios.json | CLI/capture pass loaded protocol to validate_scenario_contract/audit_scenarios; stable IDs and required obligations validated | WIRED |
| fidelity_review.py → fidelity_receipts.py | Imports and calls read_receipt, validate_receipt, contained_path, identify_file before export | WIRED |
| viewer.mjs → generated review/media | fetch('review.json') supplies per-side media/events to createPairController; controller enforces exclusive mute and independent times | WIRED; actual media/browser pending |
| capabilities.json → REQUIREMENTS.md | Validator extracts exact IDs and rejects incomplete coverage; all 33 IDs accounted for | WIRED |
| fidelity_ledger.py → viewer ledger | Canonical export/current/history projection copied during checkpoint assembly and rendered by renderCapabilities | WIRED |
| Program.cs → FidelityObservation.cs | Optional outer using owner passed through Run; real post-Step acceptsInput/state/control/raw SDL hooks call observer | WIRED |
| Observed JSONL → shared receipts | Versioned session/case/elapsed/tick payload validated through process interoperability and collector; synthetic scope preserved | WIRED contract; real route pending |
| prepare-fidelity-checkpoint.sh → fidelity_checkpoint.py | Explicit Python invocation consumes original inventory and completed sealed packages | WIRED |
| Windows collector → shared receipts | Emits schema-versioned raw receipts, exact content identities and failure states; documented agent-owned validation/import normalizes returned reviewed records | WIRED contract; actual returned data pending |
| fidelity_capture.py → Linux package/observer | Uses actual package executable/assets and --fidelity-* arguments after real display/audio preflight | WIRED; hardware execution pending |
| Linux receipts → review/acceptance | Collected diagnostics undergo shared validation/import and explicit current selection; real failed Linux receipt remains open | WIRED failure path; successful route pending |
| Returned Windows/Linux results → strict audit | audit reads current.json, validates contained selected receipts and receipt_sha256 binding, checks all 120 slots and named reviews | WIRED implementation; human return pending |
| phase01-baseline.md → capability ledger | Same open acceptance/current scope retained; documented reconciliation updates receipt-bound current/history after return | WIRED present baseline; future reconciliation pending |
Data-Flow Trace (Level 4)
| Rendered/accepted value | Actual source and flow | Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Capability navigation/current/history/discrepancies | capabilities.json → validate/export → sealed protocol/capability-ledger.json → review.json → renderCapabilities | FLOWING: real maintained evidence; unimplemented and missing scopes remain visible |
| Paired video/audio/event times | Actual imported receipt artifacts/hashes → _side/_events export → review.json → media/controller | Implementation wired; current source is explicitly missing, not synthetic original footage |
| Observer input/state/elapsed | Actual SDL/control/post-Step data → retained observer → bounded JSONL → collector/receipt validation | FLOWING in bounded regressions; current complete physical capture unavailable |
| Native acceptance totals | Explicit selected actual receipt files + content identities → audit_scenarios + CHECKS → strict report | FLOWING: actual failed diagnostic yields 0/120, errors [], human_needed |
Missing media is expected open evidence and is displayed as such; no hardcoded empty success path or invented original recording closes it.
Existing Behavioral Evidence Reviewed
This completion pass did not rerun tests or launch services. Commands/results below are from retained execution receipts/logs, not SUMMARY assertions; fresh owner queries covered artifact presence, story validity and decision coverage.
| Evidence | Recorded invocation/result | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Integrated local suite | artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json and .log: scripts/test.sh, exit 0, 782.049626s; 556 Python (180 fidelity), 27 Node, 23 managed observer, 2 HUD, 51 managed entry-point invocations, 36 rendered GPU receipts, zero Vulkan errors, 539 originals | Before later tooling-only review fixes; dummy audio/headless checks are not physical/native baseline capture |
| Final tooling regression | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/python-fidelity-final.log: 191 tests, 43.355s, OK | Includes final copy-state artifact-root fix; no new runtime change or full GPU rerun claimed |
| Media controller | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/node-viewer-direct.log: 27 pass, 0 fail/skipped; named independent seek/drift, exclusive mute, rejected play, buffering, decode and full-tail assertions inspected | Media doubles exercise controller transitions, not actual browser decoding/audibility |
| Preservation | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/original-preservation.log: 539 unchanged originals | Byte preservation at check time; final P1 session conduct still needs disposition |
| Readiness | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/readiness-final.json plus verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json: 11,001 members, materials_ready true, human_needed | Sealed runtime provenance retained as 446930d dirty true / diff 90cef956…; later tooling revision does not relabel it |
| Strict acceptance | artifacts/fidelity/01-review-fixes/acceptance-final.json: require-complete exit 1, errors [], accepted 0/120, all ten findings pending | Expected open evidence; no malformed acceptance input or observed code failure |
No phase-declared shell probe requiring a separate new execution was identified; the phase relies on the retained local CLI/test/preflight evidence. No full suite was repeated in this completion pass.
Requirements Coverage
All four accountable requirement IDs are declared across the seven PLANs; no Phase 1 requirement is orphaned. Pending is retained in REQUIREMENTS.md.
| Requirement | Source PLANs | Evidence and remaining dependency | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| EVID-01 | 01,05,06,07 | 539 unchanged originals; bounded isolated staging, canonical inventory and pre/post checks implemented. Final actual session preservation/P1 remains pending | Pending — current preservation verified; final human disposition required |
| EVID-02 | 01,02,04,05,07 | Original-DxWnd collector/protocol/identity/review tooling ready; 0/40 actual original obligations and A1/original-boundary review open | Pending — NEEDS HUMAN |
| EVID-03 | 02,03,07 | All 33 full-game requirements represented in 25 capabilities/six groups; source/implementation/platform/history/discrepancy/open acceptance traceable. Returned-evidence reconciliation and P3 remain open | Pending — ledger implementation verified; final human/reconciliation dependency |
| EVID-04 | 01,02,04,05,06,07 | Native collectors, observer and exact package binding implemented; failed Linux physical preflight retained, no accepted native route; 0/80 accepted | Pending — NEEDS HUMAN |
Decision Coverage
Owner query: 16/16 trackable CONTEXT decisions honored, not_honored []. “All trackable CONTEXT.md decisions are honored by shipped artifacts.” Advisory gate only; it does not change acceptance.
Test Quality and Anti-Patterns
Active tests assert concrete identity bytes, rejection behavior, monotonic ownership/state, media-controller transitions and acceptance classification. Test-generated metadata/media are explicitly synthetic fixtures: they verify validators/controller behavior and are never original/native fidelity oracles. The complete-metadata positive matrix test cannot establish actual physical execution; strict real matrix stays 0/120.
The targeted completion scan found no unreferenced TBD/FIXME/XXX or disabled requirement-test markers in the fidelity source/tests/scripts/observer scope; the prior completed 40-file debt/skip scan is retained. Expected empty initial review and false human-review fields preserve missing evidence. They are not stubs claiming completion. No new blocking anti-pattern was established.
Existing gates remain recorded: security 22/22 mitigated, zero open; validation automation complete with manual checks open; independent review verification closes all five historical findings after 02d182f. UI review was explicitly disabled for this phase by the recorded gate configuration; TDD is inactive. These gates were not reopened. Broad tooling feedback 43.355s exceeds its 30s quick target (WARNING), with no effect on native acceptance.
Human Verification Required
Ten named findings remain pending. Collect, observe and return one complete local result tree following docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md and its Windows/Linux subguides. The integration agent owns evidence-backed normalization, reviewed-copy creation, hash validation, import, current selection, ledger reconciliation and final strict audit after return. Raw receipts remain immutable. Positive human findings must never be generated automatically.
1. A1 — Capture and observe the isolated original through the selected DxWnd setup
Test: A1 — Capture and observe the isolated original through the selected DxWnd setup using the combined-session guide.
Expected: Complete 40 original-Windows-DxWnd obligations; observe moving game imagery and intelligible game audio, retaining actual executable/profile/copy inventories and wrapper/configuration limitations.
Why human: Original execution and audiovisual truth are unobserved; the backstop abstains with insufficient_spec.
2. A2 — Exercise actual paired recordings in the identified browser
Test: A2 — Exercise actual paired recordings in the identified browser using the combined-session guide.
Expected: Both real recordings decode, play at actual speed, seek to their own observed events, preserve full tails and switch exclusive audio without concealing elapsed time.
Why human: Controller tests use media doubles; they cannot establish real codec/browser/physical-audio behavior. Backstop: insufficient_spec.
3. EVID-02-unclassified — Review original capture boundaries and limitations
Test: EVID-02-unclassified — Review original capture boundaries and limitations using the combined-session guide.
Expected: Document observed original/DxWnd launch, crop, aspect, timing, recording boundaries and retained/fresh lifetimes for the actual reference captures.
Why human: This flagged assumption cannot be inferred from prepared settings or synthetic metadata.
4. EVID-04-unclassified — Collect and inspect both native platform routes
Test: EVID-04-unclassified — Collect and inspect both native platform routes using the combined-session guide.
Expected: Complete 40 native Windows and 40 native Linux obligations with actual OS/GPU/driver/Vulkan/SDL/source/package/resource identity and observed route/input/audio continuity.
Why human: Windows is cross-published only; current Linux TTY/auto_null preflight cannot capture native physical gameplay.
5. P1 — Resolve the original-preservation prohibition explicitly
Test: P1 — Resolve the original-preservation prohibition explicitly using the combined-session guide.
Expected: Confirm authoritative originals were never executed or changed; compare all 539 recorded hashes and generated-copy pre/retained/post inventories after the session.
Why human: Descriptor-less unresolved prohibition requires explicit disposition; current preserved hashes do not prove future session conduct.
6. P2 — Resolve the honest-comparison prohibition explicitly
Test: P2 — Resolve the honest-comparison prohibition explicitly using the combined-session guide.
Expected: Confirm genuine original media, no retiming or concealed drift, no mixed simultaneous soundtracks, and visible review gain/derivation provenance.
Why human: Unverified-prohibition — human review recommended; genuine playback and perceived audiovisual comparison require observation.
7. P3 — Resolve the history/full-scope/native-transparency prohibition explicitly
Test: P3 — Resolve the history/full-scope/native-transparency prohibition explicitly using the combined-session guide.
Expected: Confirm all 33 requirements and unimplemented content stay visible; conflicting/superseded evidence and native/Wine/component/cross-publish distinctions are preserved after reconciliation.
Why human: Unverified-prohibition — human review recommended; final returned-evidence reconciliation requires explicit judgment.
8. browser — Review the complete local comparison interface
Test: browser — Review the complete local comparison interface using the combined-session guide.
Expected: With real captures, verify readable independent clocks/drift, keyboard controls, raw unobstructed default views, optional annotations/differences and visible loading/error/tail states.
Why human: No actual browser visual/usability/codec review has been performed.
9. paired_review — Compare all corresponding actual recordings and record discrepancies
Test: paired_review — Compare all corresponding actual recordings and record discrepancies using the combined-session guide.
Expected: Review matched events, imagery and sound across the required cases, retaining raw drift and justified system-specific observations without invented tolerances.
Why human: No corresponding original/native pair or completed visual/audible comparison exists.
10. physical_input — Exercise visible native gameplay and actual audible devices
Test: physical_input — Exercise visible native gameplay and actual audible devices using the combined-session guide.
Expected: On Linux and Windows use physical supported inputs through lab → VR04 → lab → outside, natural/skipped and fresh/retained cases, held input, banked jumps, landing and idle; confirm real display/audio output.
Why human: Injected/headless/GPU/dummy-audio fixtures prove narrower behavior and cannot satisfy physical-input or audibility acceptance.
Acceptance Conclusion
Autonomous preparation is complete; the promised real comparison outcome remains human_needed. No implementation BLOCKER was established in this bounded completion. The observable absence of original/native accepted captures is a documented human/external evidence dependency, explicitly kept open by the roadmap contract, not silently passed.
A1/A2 are unverified non-inferable checks (insufficient_spec); P1/P2/P3 are unverified-prohibition — human review recommended, with no automatic resolution. No later phase specifically replaces Phase 1 capture/review obligations, so none are deferred. No phase completion, advancement, commit or push was performed.
The fingerprint was produced by the owner CLI query verification.fingerprint over the listed actual source/test/document/evidence inputs; its returned fields are copied verbatim. Planning PLAN/SUMMARY coverage was added by the owner. SUMMARYs supply intended interfaces, not proof of behavior.
Verified: 2026-11-14T05:34:19Z
Verifier: gsd-verifier