Files

197 lines
12 KiB
Markdown

---
phase: 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline
plan: "07"
status: complete
completion_scope: autonomous preparation and pending-evidence reconciliation
acceptance: human_needed
subsystem: testing
tags: [fidelity, acceptance, checkpoint, local-regressions]
requires:
- phase: 01-06
provides: Linux collector and failed native preflight diagnostic
provides:
- Strict ready/audit gates and fresh local combined-session materials
- Pending original/native/human acceptance and exact reconciliation mapping
- Counted consolidated local regressions and measured final evidence status
affects: [phase01-acceptance, phase02]
tech-stack:
added: []
patterns: [receipt-bound human findings, immutable materials, explicit current selection, positive test counts]
key-files:
created: [tools/recon/fidelity_acceptance.py, tests/test_fidelity_acceptance.py, docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md, docs/evidence/phase01-baseline.md]
modified: [tools/recon/fidelity_checkpoint.py, tests/test_fidelity_checkpoint.py, docs/evidence/capabilities.json, scripts/test.sh, docs/progress.md, docs/tasks.md, docs/decisions.md, docs/compatibility.md]
key-decisions:
- "Ready materials and local regressions never substitute for actual original/native acceptance; all 120 obligations and ten named human findings remain open."
- "The integration agent reconciles returned collector records through specified artifact mappings; the tester collects, observes and returns one combined session."
requirements-completed: []
actuals:
tokens: 18163
tasks: 2
commits: 5
plan_head_before: d18f551a26f90cd645309dcd545295911b581357
plan_head_after: 472500bf4e191c2080764471b6b08486c1909b3a
duration: "4h 36min observed commit-to-closeout elapsed, including quota pause; full suite 782.05s"
completed: 2026-11-13
coverage:
- id: D1
description: Immutable readiness and strict rejection of missing original/native/human evidence
verification:
- kind: integration
ref: tests/test_fidelity_acceptance.py; 23 checks in completed local suite
status: pass
- kind: integration
ref: fidelity_acceptance.py ready; 11000 immutable files
status: pass
human_judgment: false
- id: D2
description: Actual combined original-DxWnd/native Linux/native Windows capture and review
verification:
- kind: manual_procedural
ref: docs/evidence/checkpoint-session.md; acceptance.json 0/120
status: unknown
human_judgment: true
rationale: Actual moving content, physical input, audibility and paired playback remain unavailable; strict acceptance exits 1.
- id: D3
description: Counted fidelity regressions integrated with the existing complete local suite
verification:
- kind: integration
ref: artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json; exit 0 in 782.0496263504028 seconds
status: pass
human_judgment: false
---
# Phase 01 Plan 07: Strict Fidelity Acceptance Checkpoint Summary
**Fresh 11,000-file offline materials pass readiness and the complete local suite; strict acceptance retains 0/120 original/native obligations and ten human judgments.**
Autonomous preparation and truthful pending-status reconciliation are complete.
Tasks 01-07-01 and 01-07-03 are complete. Task 01-07-02's permitted unavailable-
evidence projection is committed; its actual combined capture/review remains
pending. `status: complete` describes that preparation scope, never Phase 1 or
EVID acceptance. All EVID requirements remain Pending. Phase 2 is not advanced.
The stale quota handoff is retained for primary review/consumption separately.
## Performance and Accounting
- Earliest production-task commit: 2026-11-13T17:09:46Z; closeout: approximately 21:46Z.
- Observed elapsed interval includes the quota pause; active execution time was not measured continuously.
- Full authorized local suite: 782.0496263504028s, exit 0; runner reports 783s.
- Realized diff: 72,652 characters / 4 = 18,163 tokens, including committed quota metadata.
- Persisted plan ledger measures five commits before this summary; hashes above bound that measurement.
- Two fully completed tasks; one pending actual human task with its permitted documentation complete.
## Task Commits
| Task | Commit | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 01-07-01 RED | d78b135 | 18 intentional missing-API assertions fail; machine RED_EVIDENCE_OK |
| 01-07-01 GREEN | 026def9 | Strict audit, 23 passing tests, fresh final bundle and reconciliation checklist |
| 01-07-02 pending projection | fc5e936 | Capability ledger retains failed diagnostic and unresolved human states |
| Quota checkpoint | b732256 | Existing handoff/state only; no production behavior change |
| 01-07-03 | 472500b | Counted existing regressions and actual full-suite/status results |
## Verification Results
The complete suite ran once after the scoped reporter correction; its completed
receipt is `artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.json` and full output is
`artifacts/fidelity/01-07-full-suite.log`. No duplicate final suite was run.
| Verification | Actual result |
|---|---|
| Python discovery | 556 tests in 68.110s; 180 fidelity across all eight modules |
| Fidelity module counts | acceptance 23, capture 23, checkpoint 24, ledger 31, observation 7, review 21, scenarios 22, sessions 29 |
| Node viewer | 27 tests pass with explicit TAP reporter |
| Standalone managed observer | 23 checks pass |
| HUD Python | 2 separate tests in 0.171s |
| Managed entry points/build | All 51 test-project invocations and main build pass |
| Vulkan | 36 rendered receipts across 32 device groups; 27 saved readbacks; zero reported validation errors |
| Material regression | 17 Vulkan material/readback assertions pass, zero validation errors |
| SDL audio | Existing dummy-audio effect/stream/scene/cutscene checks pass; audibility remains unverified |
| Preservation | Verified 539 unchanged original files |
| Final readiness recheck | 11,000 immutable files; materials_ready=true, acceptance=human_needed |
| Final strict audit recheck | Exit 1; errors=[], accepted 0/120; ten human findings pending |
Optional `NEUTRON_WINDOW_TEST=1` checks were not enabled; no new native window,
physical-input, audible, original gameplay or native Windows execution is claimed.
Existing NU1900 unavailable vulnerability-metadata warnings remain unrelated.
First attempt: Python 556 passed in 71.765s and Node 27 passed, but the new TAP
count guard rejected Node's default spec reporter. Its 74.647s attempt/log is
retained as `01-07-full-suite-attempt1.{json,log}`. Explicit TAP passed focused
checks and the completed full rerun.
## Exact Evidence and Package Identity
- Final bundle: `dist/fidelity/phase01`; READY SHA-256 `48100025fbdcbb5310bdae28b5cae1e8f17412aa7b03be5f823616cd88211951`.
- Manifest SHA-256: `46610a4029f1341e7f48147370a81daaa8ff799a60fba388b641a0678d2032aa`.
- Exact tool/package identities: `artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json`.
- Runtime source: `446930d2a30d6d616c60ac5e59e4169a840bea09`, dirty true, diff `90cef95669caece53fe2d2c4736cf2ac05ed27f5d25ca03ab572589686bcb73d`. Later tool/docs commits do not relabel existing packages.
- Actual failed receipt: `linux-01-06-matrix-preflight-linux`, imported under final `results/imported/`; diagnostic viewer: `results/failed-linux-review/index.html`.
- Final audit: `dist/fidelity/phase01/results/acceptance.json`; actual capture and human acceptance remain OPEN.
- Capability validation: 25 capabilities, 33 requirements, 33 reconciled rows, six groups; acceptance OPEN.
No runtime source changed in task 3, no package rebuild/relabel occurred, and no
originals, generated packages, media or traces were uploaded. All remain local.
## Files Created/Modified
`fidelity_acceptance.py` and its dedicated tests separate readiness from strict
acceptance. The existing checkpoint assembler/tests add required final materials
and tool provenance. `checkpoint-session.md` prepares one combined review and
`phase01-baseline.md` records actual/pending findings. `capabilities.json` retains
the failed receipt and unresolved current states. `scripts/test.sh` counts the
existing fidelity Python/Node/observer checks; the four root status reports cite
the completed suite, exact identities and pending acceptance. Planning artifacts
record the quota interruption and final autonomous preparation scope.
## Decisions Made
Prepared bytes, diagnostic fixtures and local regression success do not replace
actual original/native receipts or human judgments. Reconciliation remains an
agent-owned operation after one combined tester session; no fragmented early
capture request or new universal fidelity tolerance is introduced.
## Deviations from Plan
- Approved ownership extension: minimal checkpoint MATERIALS expansion, actual tool_source metadata and existing material-membership assertion update make the final immutable bundle contain Linux/audit dependencies; no second assembler/capture subsystem.
- Baseline pending report was created with task 1 because it must exist before immutable assembly; task 2 actual capture acceptance remains open.
- **[Rule 1 - Bug]** Task 3's new positive-count guard expected TAP while installed Node emitted spec. Explicit `--test-reporter=tap` fixes that scoped runner mismatch; focused 27 checks and complete rerun pass. Commit: `472500b`.
- Quota reserve interrupted closeout; the retained quota commit did not add behavior. The completed suite was recovered after reset without repeating it.
## TDD Gate Compliance
Task 1 RED preceded GREEN: `d78b135` then `026def9`. Saved
`artifacts/fidelity/01-07-red.{log,json}` records RED_EVIDENCE_OK. Prior semantic
inspection confirmed the empty-matrix test ran and failed on planned API existence,
without load/setup failure. Final suite executes all 23 acceptance checks.
## Deferred Issues and Human Dependencies
Actual original-DxWnd 40/native Windows 40/native Linux 40 obligations remain OPEN.
A1/A2, both EVID-02/EVID-04 unclassified assumptions, P1/P2/P3, browser,
paired_review and physical_input are the ten pending named findings. No strict
acceptance verification passed; its expected nonzero result records that missing
evidence. `.planning/WINDOWS.md` entry 3 tracks this unmet truth; entry 2 retains
the Linux capture access dependency. The primary reviews readiness before the
single combined human session. The roadmap source-backed continuation exception
does not waive these dependencies or authorize a phase transition here.
## Known Stubs
None preventing autonomous preparation. Checklist JSON metavariables are explicit
human-review templates, never positive findings. Empty review dictionaries in
negative tests and fail-closed audit defaults intentionally exercise missing
evidence; no production UI/data stub was introduced. Existing gameplay admission
gates remain unchanged. No new security surface beyond the planned local evidence
file/import boundaries was introduced.
## Self-Check: PASSED
All created source/test/checklist/baseline files, final local checkpoint, completed
suite receipt and exact identity receipt exist. All five recorded commits are
ancestors of the measured HEAD. Final readiness passes and strict audit retains
errors=[], 0/120 and ten pending findings. Unrelated `tools.yaml` is preserved.
## Independent review closure
Five confirmed findings were fixed and independently verified; see01-REVIEW.md,01-FIX-REPORT.md,01-REVIEW-VERIFY.md and01-REVIEW-DISPOSITION.md. Final refinement02d182f requires actual artifact bytes at the scenario boundary;191 fidelity checks pass43.355s. The new checkpoint has11,001 immutable entries with current local identities in artifacts/fidelity/verification/01-07-final-checkpoint.json; prior identity notes remain historical. All22 planned security threats are closed, while actual0/120 acceptance and ten named human findings stayOPEN. No original/native acceptance or phase advancement is implied.