6.4 KiB
phase, verified, review_path, fix_report_path, verified_head, findings_verified, fixed, open, findings, status
| phase | verified | review_path | fix_report_path | verified_head | findings_verified | fixed | open | findings | status | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline | 2026-11-13T22:19:18Z | .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-REVIEW.md | .planning/phases/01-reproducible-fidelity-baseline/01-FIX-REPORT.md | 02d182f35d |
5 | 5 | 0 |
|
clean |
Phase 01 review-fix verification
All five fixes are verified. The final CR-03 refinement requires actual backing artifacts for named copy-state identities and rejects the hash-only records that survived its first fix. No reviewed finding remains open.
| Finding | Disposition | Independent verification |
|---|---|---|
| CR-01 | FIXED | The selected path is retained and its own digest is compared with the human finding. The sibling-digest and absent-digest regressions leave human checks pending; the actual selected-file digest satisfies that boundary. |
| CR-02 | FIXED | Complete baseline records and their recomputed digest bind original pre/post/package/resources. The explicit executed original_member binds executable size/header/hash. Wrong executable/member and inconsistent inventories are rejected; independently identified writable copy_post changes remain allowed. |
| CR-03 | FIXED | Scenario validation now checks the actual named copy-pre artifact for both lifetimes and the retained snapshot for retained runs. Previous hash-only reproductions and an isolated retained-snapshot reproduction are rejected; valid named state files still qualify. |
| WR-01 | FIXED | Assembly exports the validated ledger projection; readiness compares current/history with the sealed projection. The preparation-to-bundled-renderer check preserves named current/superseded records. The standalone-transfer check needs no source Git checkout, and missing viewer history is rejected. |
| WR-02 | FIXED | A real Linux-hosted PowerShell finalizer reproduction recovered an incomplete-only synthetic run as aborted. Initial raw bytes and session identity survived, end clocks remained absent, captured promotion was rejected, and shared validation plus atomic import succeeded with acceptance false. |
CR-03 refinement verified
Original classification: BLOCKER
Current disposition: FIXED by 02d182f35de643f9d68699b2fff1d219dd132edb, with regression 48fca0d.
File: /home/cristian/codex/Neutron/GamePort/tools/recon/fidelity_receipts.py:667-678
Related: /home/cristian/codex/Neutron/GamePort/tools/recon/fidelity_receipts.py:383-385
At a821754, _scenario_observation() compared continuity digests with named identity strings while the generic validator skipped dictionaries without path. The refinement now passes the receipt root to scenario validation and calls _checked_artifact() on the actual named state records before comparing digests. The scenario audit and Linux capture matrix both pass their artifact root; their direct test callers were updated as well.
The bounded reproduction below uses existing synthetic metadata fixtures and launches no game. It previously demonstrated the gap and now demonstrates rejection for both native lifetimes:
from test_fidelity_scenarios import FidelityScenarios
import fidelity_receipts as receipts
fixture = FidelityScenarios()
fixture.setUp()
try:
for lifetime in ('fresh', 'retained'):
value, root = fixture.receipt(
lifetime + '-natural-ordinary', 'dialogue-return')
value['identity']['copy_pre'] = {'sha256': 'f' * 64}
value['continuity']['copy_pre_sha256'] = 'f' * 64
if lifetime == 'retained':
value['identity']['retained_copy'] = {'sha256': 'e' * 64}
value['continuity']['retained_copy_sha256'] = 'e' * 64
result = receipts.audit_scenarios(
fixture.protocol(), [(value, root)])
print(lifetime, result['accepted'], result['invalid'])
finally:
fixture.doCleanups()
Run from the repository with PYTHONPATH=tests:tools/recon. Earlier output at a821754 was fresh 1 [] and retained 1 []. Rerunning at 02d182f gives zero accepted slots and Reference must be a bounded relative POSIX path in each invalid list. A third reproduction retaining valid copy-pre but supplying only a hash for identity.retained_copy is rejected independently. The unmodified fresh and retained metadata controls each still accept one slot.
Additional verification: Four selected scenario tests passed in 0.424 seconds: backing-file rejection for both lifetimes, named continuity binding, unrelated retained-snapshot rejection, and complete positive coverage of all 120 metadata slots. The new backing-file test covers hash-only, missing-file and wrong-size state identities, including the retained snapshot. This closes the reported artifact-binding gap without changing the four other verified fixes.
Verification evidence and limits
Read the historical review, fix report and actual source/test diffs for 5569bc2, bda35e5, 6e5ee0b, 548c97a, 2608517, and a821754, then the final 48fca0d regression and 02d182f refinement. Initially ran 11 selected Python tests in 2.109 seconds, all passing: selected-file review binding; original executable/member and inventory rejection; mutable generated-copy allowance; complete positive metadata matrix; standalone readiness without Git; malformed viewer history; actual assembled model through its bundled renderer; named pre/retained continuity; and aborted missing-end-clock import. The additional hash-only identity gap discovered during that verification is closed by the independently repeated checks above.
Separately exercised the actual PowerShell recovery function with a disposable synthetic prepared checkpoint, rejected captured promotion, recovered raw media, compared both raw initial copies byte-for-byte, verified absent end clocks, validated and imported the resulting open aborted receipt. This was Linux-hosted tooling execution, not native Windows evidence.
No full suite, whole 11,001-file checkpoint readiness/hash walk, original execution or gameplay capture was repeated. The primary's current bundle identities and pending 0/120 human acceptance remain separate evidence; this verification does not promote them. Source and tests were read-only, no commit was made, and unrelated concurrent report edits were preserved.
Historical 01-REVIEW.md is unchanged; its SHA-256 is 493c0b9b7b491f7dcc896d6cfda675ced837f56ee32daf2bbf1cd98f1527f74c.