227 lines
20 KiB
Markdown
227 lines
20 KiB
Markdown
# Compatibility and validation
|
|
|
|
Compilation, native runtime, original behavior and full feature completion are
|
|
separate evidence categories. **The game is not fully reconstructed/playable yet.**
|
|
|
|
C4 continuation (2026-10-26): REA/bytes recover the bounded47BD80 sphere kernel;
|
|
ten isolated original Wine32 synthetic cases pass with explicitly guarded fixture
|
|
rebasing. The managed component matches numeric references; live capsule replacement
|
|
remains gated. Source-root overhead velocity reflection/mode1 jump/fire cancellation
|
|
is integrated for LV1B/VR04/LEV1, including without control and with the modern
|
|
camera query disabled. Full sound/gadget cleanup and other scene filters remain.
|
|
Registration/repeated Init and shared-eye handoff reports distinguish recovery
|
|
from pending runtime changes. See checkpoint/collision-response.md and linked reports.
|
|
|
|
Final scripts/test.sh passes in artifacts/collision-response/integration-final.log:
|
|
104 Python checks plus separate HUD checks,25 movement groups, five new sphere
|
|
groups, remaining managed checks,27 zero-error enabled-validation GPU completions,
|
|
SDL dummy lifecycle and539 unchanged original hashes. Both input-only routes use
|
|
the source geometry queries and retain their progression/contact checks. Native
|
|
Linux GTX1070 at1280x720 passes Carl/control, jetpack SDL keys/resize and debug
|
|
tools/checkpoint reload (four commands, five renders), zero validation errors.
|
|
The original component probe is not whole-game or native Windows validation.
|
|
|
|
Both self-contained packages identify clean57dfcc6, source_dirty=no. Standalone
|
|
Linux from /tmp passes the control-phase fixture and nondefault tutorial/RETURN
|
|
assertions. These release invocations lack validation layers; enabled source and
|
|
native-window evidence above is separate. Logs: artifacts/collision-response/
|
|
package.log, package-control.log and package-return.log. Baseline untouched;
|
|
Windows cross-publication adds no native Windows runtime claim.
|
|
|
|
Control-phase continuation (2026-10-26): body/fire eligibility and ordered raw
|
|
preparations are source-byte guarded separately from port behavior. Targeted24
|
|
movement groups, coupled director/preparation tests and the airborne control
|
|
fixture pass. Native Linux GTX1070 at1280x720 passes Carl/control-phase, F1 pause/
|
|
Force Control and F3/tools/same-window checkpoint checks, all with enabled Vulkan
|
|
validation and zero errors. The input-only route uses the actual binding and
|
|
Down braking at turns; source score/task/inventory/contact checks still pass.
|
|
Detailed gaps: checkpoint/control-phase-implementation.md. Native Windows and
|
|
original whole-game comparisons remain unverified for this chunk.
|
|
Full scripts/test.sh passes in artifacts/uncontrolled-phases/integration-final.log:
|
|
93 Python checks,24 movement groups plus remaining managed groups,27 zero-error
|
|
GPU renders with enabled validation, SDL dummy checks and539 unchanged hashes.
|
|
REA6.8.0/Ghidra12.1.4 decompiled five selected procedures locally using a generated
|
|
copy; complete Evidence is retained.421FB0 lacked a recognized procedure; that
|
|
limit is recorded without replacing its existing byte/vtable evidence. Static
|
|
pseudocode is not original execution. See rea.md for local installation and CLI.
|
|
|
|
Both self-contained packages identify clean commit c285b57 (source_dirty=no).
|
|
Standalone Linux launches from /tmp pass the airborne control-phase fixture and
|
|
nondefault tutorial/RETURN scalar, root, companion and availability assertions.
|
|
Release validation layers are unavailable; enabled-validation results above are
|
|
separate. Logs: artifacts/uncontrolled-phases/package.log, package-control.log
|
|
and package-return.log. Preserved baseline untouched; Windows cross-publication
|
|
adds no native Windows runtime evidence.
|
|
|
|
Retained-state continuation (2026-10-26):14 new source-evidence tests and22
|
|
movement groups cover named property loading, cleanup/Init/PostLoad/control
|
|
boundaries and bounded route scalar carry. Corrected full tutorial/lab gadget
|
|
availability and TSK/unknown-state tests pass. An isolated Wine32 component probe
|
|
executes copied original vector accessors and43A750 with synthetic fixture vtables
|
|
and invalid sound handle; source targets are byte-guarded. It confirms body-field
|
|
writes and unrelated sentinel preservation, not full loader/gameplay or native
|
|
Windows behavior. Evidence: artifacts/retained-lifecycle/original-probe/wine.log.
|
|
|
|
Integration:84 Python checks, all managed groups and26 GPU render checks pass
|
|
with zero enabled-validation errors. Final nondefault mode1/hold.625/fire6.125
|
|
ordinary-load replay independently checks jump/body resets on tutorial and RETURN;
|
|
all539 original hashes unchanged. A fixed200ms effects-smoke baseline failed under
|
|
load; paused stream construction plus a bounded consumption poll removes that
|
|
sampling assumption (the initial failure did not record its queue baseline). All four SDL dummy audio checks pass in audio-final.log; final route is in
|
|
route-final.log. No new native Windows runtime verification.
|
|
Both self-contained packages rebuilt from clean9ad5a8e, source_dirty=no. Linux
|
|
standalone launch from /tmp passes nondefault lab→VR04→lab scalar/body/RETURN
|
|
assertions, with the same presentation instance retained. That release invocation
|
|
has validation unavailable; source GPU enabled-validation evidence remains separate.
|
|
Logs: artifacts/retained-lifecycle/package.log and package-route.log.
|
|
|
|
Debug expansion (2026-10-25): full scripts/test.sh passes, with70 Python checks,
|
|
21 movement groups, debug page/overlay groups, real SDL dummy pause/mute timing,
|
|
remaining managed/GPU routes and539 unchanged original hashes. Native Linux
|
|
GTX1070 at1920x1080 passes F1/Tab/F3, flight during a source cutscene, input capture,
|
|
camera/audio controls, checkpoint save/load and same-window rebuild. Enabled Vulkan
|
|
validation reports zero errors. Headless Player1920x1080 and Systems2560x1080
|
|
screenshots fit; see artifacts/debug-expansion/. SDL_SetAudioStreamGain is present
|
|
in the packaged Windows SDL3 DLL export table. Cross-build/export evidence does
|
|
not add native Windows runtime or original-game behavior verification.
|
|
Both platform packages rebuilt from clean d783898, source_dirty=no. Standalone
|
|
Linux package launched from /tmp with Player page/noclip1920x1080 passes on
|
|
llvmpipe; that invocation lacks validation layers. Evidence: package.log and
|
|
package-smoke.log under artifacts/debug-expansion/.
|
|
|
|
Latest implementation continuation: controlled player phase ordering, route static
|
|
camera query and PostLoad gadget availability pass the full `scripts/test.sh`.
|
|
Evidence: artifacts/implementation/integration-final.log;70 Python regressions,
|
|
20 movement groups,11 new camera groups,13 existing support groups, remaining
|
|
managed groups, GPU story/practice/RETURN/Carl/objective/jetpack/animation checks,
|
|
SDL dummy lifecycle and539 unchanged original hashes. GPU validation is enabled
|
|
and every run reports zero errors. Native Windows runtime and original-game
|
|
comparison are not added by these tests. Known limits remain explicit in the
|
|
current checkpoint coverage/implementation reports.
|
|
Both self-contained packages now identify clean09cf117. Linux release smoke from
|
|
`/tmp` passes practice/RETURN (including input order and gadget availability) and
|
|
outside load; see linux-package-return.log and linux-package-outside.log under
|
|
artifacts/implementation/. Those release invocations have validation unavailable;
|
|
the enabled-validation evidence is the full integration run above. Windows is
|
|
cross-published, with no additional native Windows runtime claim.
|
|
|
|
Architecture checkpoint: see `checkpoint/review.md` for coverage and remaining
|
|
gates. C1 objective/task order and C2 per-actor Carl callback corrections pass the
|
|
full `scripts/test.sh` integration, all GPU runs with zero Vulkan validation
|
|
errors. Final Python discovery passes62 tests including the additional source
|
|
evidence follow-ups. All539 original hashes remain unchanged. These checks do not
|
|
add native Windows or original whole-game runtime verification; earlier Windows
|
|
user reports remain limited to their tested builds and route.
|
|
Self-contained Linux/Windows packages rebuilt from clean531883a. The Linux release
|
|
package passes the60-frame Carl held-input/control-lock smoke from `/tmp`;
|
|
validation layers were unavailable for that invocation. Current Windows release
|
|
is cross-published, not newly native-runtime verified. Later loader-provenance
|
|
edits affect evidence/tests only; runtime code is unchanged from that package.
|
|
|
|
| Feature | Implemented / tested | Evidence and limits |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| Original preservation | Verified after extraction/runtime tests | All539 original SHA-256 hashes unchanged |
|
|
| GAM Python / C# | All35 files,3299 entities | Exact Python round-trip; C# corpus/start/corruption checks |
|
|
| OMT recovery | All100 archives audited | 2155meshes,2183materials,1614textures,875RIFF, zero failures |
|
|
| C# original loaders | Linux runtime | All128 PNG /254 ASE base meshes; morph/base UV tests |
|
|
| .NET10 Linux build | Pass, zero warnings/errors | Local SDK10.0.402/runtime10.0.13 |
|
|
| Windows x64 publish | Pass | Correct PE32+ app and SDL3.dll; initial native rendering user-reported |
|
|
| Windows story/practice package under Wine64 | Preliminary headless/window pass |12s story;12-frame practice pause/N/resume/resize and original streams; simulation matches Linux; validation disabled |
|
|
| Corrected Windows preview under Wine64 | Preliminary window pass | Six frames, key2 animation switch, resize800x600, exit0; validation disabled |
|
|
| Windows walking package under Wine64 | Preliminary240-step window pass | SDL arrows/Shift, walking/jump/landing and800x600 resize; matches Linux movement statistics; validation disabled |
|
|
| Linux self-contained package | Native headless/window verified |12s story without SDK/source/Original mounted; GTX1070 practice pause/N/resume/resize, zero validation errors |
|
|
| Vulkan1.3 lab | llvmpipe + GTX1070 | Real indexed/textured/depth frame/readback; validation enabled, zero errors |
|
|
| Original camera/projection | Source mapping/math + outside GPU before/after |All35 level far overrides; outside28000/tutorial50000; merged layer maximum is a port policy, per-layer masks/dynamic fog incomplete |
|
|
| Jimmy normal texture / morph | Native preview verified | Correct atlas slot0, base topology/UV retained; state speed/loop unverified |
|
|
| Standing preview placement | Corrected / Linux tested | +38.503Y from actual visible floor/base soles; exact original actor transform unresolved |
|
|
| Idle/run/jump/scratch preview | Linux keyboard + GPU tests | Default idle samples identical; 1/2/3/4 select clips; run image changes across frames |
|
|
| Null-material visibility | Binary rule implemented/tested | Original DX renderer skips null pointers; proxy geometry retained |
|
|
| SDL3 presentation/input | Linux Xvfb + GTX1070 | Six frames; injected keyboard event received |
|
|
| Swapchain resize | Linux tested | 960x720 ->800x600, zero validation errors |
|
|
| Persistent level presentation | Native GTX1070 six-load pass |One window/renderer; stable IDs/core resources, bounds/focus/fullscreen; invalid load retains rendering; zero cumulative Vulkan errors |
|
|
| Widescreen HUD/debug UI | Managed matrix + native captures/pointer pass |Uniform proportions, centered modal/F1, anchored HUD/F2;4:3/16:9/21:9/32:9, DPI and strict boundary checks |
|
|
| F1 debug menu | Managed/SDL audio tests + native Linux GTX1070 window pass |Pause/actions/input capture/resume/800x600 resize, zero validation errors;33 prepared scene/start choices; intentional modern tools, no new Windows runtime claim |
|
|
| F1 Force Control | Menu/director/interaction checks + native Linux SDL pass |Persistent override through source shots; disable/reset restores normal ownership; actual movement with neutron1a active, zero Vulkan errors; music handoff regression passes |
|
|
| F2 live debug overlay | Managed timing/layout/menu + native Linux SDL pass |Non-pausing movement, visibility/repeat/menu priority and800x600 resize; all checks true, zero Vulkan errors; session persistence; modern tools, no new Windows runtime claim |
|
|
| Focus / fullscreen | Code present, partial/unverified | Focus clears keys; fullscreen toggle not dynamically tested |
|
|
| Mouse/relative input/controller | Incomplete | SDL entry point declaration alone is not behavior |
|
|
| Audio stream | Linux dummy device | Original11025Hz mono WAV consumed10752bytes/500ms; speakers untested |
|
|
| Physics fragments/RNG | Standalone C# tests | Recovered arithmetic; controller/jump/collision state incomplete |
|
|
| Walking/jump/air controller |18 movement groups + GPU replay pass |Corrected mode1 fall-through to source air handler: acceleration/braking/turning during jumps and bursts; RETURN root placement; phase/collision/lean remain provisional |
|
|
| Static source collision |11 deterministic groups + source NC byte checks pass |2851 lab collision triangles after excluding18 NC-shape triangles; all2869 render/source triangles and325 null-material proxies retained; solver/dimensions provisional |
|
|
| Simulation cadence |18 movement groups pass | Fixed60Hz independent of60/120/144Hz rendering, ten-minute finite run; original cadence unresolved |
|
|
| Walking camera and animation | Linux headless/window pass | Original five motion clips, recovered eye180/target99; pivot, timing and obstruction solver provisional |
|
|
| Walk SDL input/resize | GTX1070/Xvfb input replay pass |Current corrected managed/headless replay1252.09; all five jump bindings produce identical300-frame powered replays,403.88 travel; zero validation errors |
|
|
| TSK saves/task gates | All12 originals byte-round-trip | Bounded parse/write, task/items/score/checkpoint CLI resume; full game-state/menu save incomplete |
|
|
| Lab CAM/MCA/AI interpreter | Source sequence/Carl lock tests + Linux GPU pass |16 intro cues; neutron1a locks move/turn/jump for all active MCA shots, restores JIM1 at completion/skip; no original comparison |
|
|
| Dynamic actors/sprites/models | Linux GPU pass |Carl/Goddard/Jimmy morphs, source Canv timing and9 original lab props; billboard/alpha, pivots and playback timing remain provisional |
|
|
| Scene music/speech | Linux dummy-device pass |CAM stops music before speech; full lab chain stays silent, DEFAULT restarts on completion/skip; reset tested. Packaged Linux/Wine64 lifecycle checks pass; speakers/latency/native Windows unverified |
|
|
| VR01 star/trophy contacts | Source-data tests pass |5-point stars,300 trophy, acquired flags and contact-enter semantics; distance/exclusions/box approximation |
|
|
| RETURN / scene reload |Source/director tests + Linux headless pass |Lab/VR04/lab restores departure root/companion using one renderer, retains STRT yaw and suppresses intro; fresh TSK loading separate; original fades unverified |
|
|
| Supplied scene availability |All35 GAMs supplied;33 have OMT geometry |Level3B/E GAMs are duplicate four-entity records apart from level code; registered OMT archives absent, normal gameplay use unverified; no substitution or established blocker |
|
|
| Lab task/contact route | Managed input replay + headless GPU pass |887 input-only movement steps with live contacts/NPC updates reachSCENE60, score150, jetpack andlevel1; separate direct-contact GPU rebuild check |
|
|
| Lab underground passage |2763-step managed input replay pass |Both switches,2 clear crossings and timed reclosure; closed-gate negative sweep; explicit riverlab/SCENE65 fixture, prior progression and original comparison unverified |
|
|
| Patrol/support |10 patrol +13 support groups pass |Source phases/profiles and8 DLL magnitude refs; Carl sensing, Goddard follow and full wall response incomplete |
|
|
| Buttons/doors | Source state tests and GPU props pass |Cooldown, hold/reversal, original model transforms; source broadphase/box order with modern narrowphase |
|
|
| Dynamic collision |10 managed groups pass |Includes actual closed/open lab bars; full source solver/activation exclusions incomplete |
|
|
| Lab objectives/practice | Source timer/O tests + managed/headless/SDL pass |Original popup slide/timeout and O latch integrated; pad/content separate; modal pause/No reset; practice highlights/controller still incomplete |
|
|
| Jetpack tutorial |14 vertical groups +16 movement groups +300-step VR04 GPU pass |Powered horizontal travel403.88, turn/brake/release and landing; rise418.98, zero validation errors; phase/shadow/collision/lean approximations |
|
|
| Powered SDL/package steering |Linux GTX1070 and preliminary Wine64 window pass |300 frames, Up/Left/Down/Shift received, resize800x600, travel403.88/landing; Linux zero validation errors, Wine validation disabled; native Windows pending |
|
|
| Default effects bank |251 exact RIFF exports, SDL dummy pass |Pickup/button/door sounds and owner-loop stop; positional/volume/channel policy incomplete; MPEG-in-RIFF bird1/id162 unsupported by SDL WAV |
|
|
| Complete scene/gameplay loop | Incomplete |Lab navigation, exact collision/pivot/cadence and original reference comparison still required |
|
|
| Menus/AI/combat/progression/saves | Incomplete | Required future work |
|
|
| Original execution | Attempted under isolated Wine11 | Window created, GL/Vulkan rendering unusable; no reference comparison |
|
|
| Native Windows functionality | User confirms lab/tutorial/lab/outside and corrected build works |User built/tested Windows; comprehensive native input/audio/resize/driver coverage and original comparison remain unverified by the agent |
|
|
|
|
Generated evidence: artifacts/full-integration-test.log, practice-window.log,
|
|
practice-transition.log, jetpack-runtime.log, final-tests.log, test-level1b.ppm, test-player.ppm,
|
|
resize-input.ppm, package-linux.ppm, extracted/audit.json and reference*/ logs.
|
|
The lab/player images have been visually inspected; they do not establish original
|
|
visual equivalence. Windows cross-publishing must not be represented as Windows
|
|
runtime validation. Package scope and prerequisites are in infrastructure.md.
|
|
|
|
Current four-fix regression evidence: artifacts/four-bugs-full-tests.log (complete
|
|
suite and539 preserved hashes), jump-binding-parity.json, outside-fixed-clip.png,
|
|
package-objective-window.log and package-carl-cutscene.log. Both platforms publish
|
|
successfully; packaged Linux popup/Carl checks pass with zero Vulkan validation
|
|
errors. The already-started Wine64 popup/O/resize check passes with validation
|
|
disabled. Further package checks were skipped at the user's request after they
|
|
reported their own Windows build works. No new agent native Windows claim is made.
|
|
|
|
Subsequent RETURN/underground checkpoint: artifacts/return-underground-tests.log
|
|
passes the complete suite (41 Python checks,18 movement groups, source checkpoint
|
|
checks, actual lab/VR04/lab rendering, underground input replay and539 unchanged
|
|
originals). RETURN restores the exact departure root and companion, retains STRT
|
|
yaw and suppresses intro, with zero Vulkan validation errors. NC registration
|
|
exclusion fixes the underground water-plane rise while retaining rendering.
|
|
Both Linux x64 and Windows x64 self-contained executables republish successfully.
|
|
No subsequent native Windows/Wine runtime check is claimed.
|
|
|
|
F1 menu checkpoint: artifacts/debug-menu-full-tests.log passes the full suite,
|
|
including actual SDL audio pause/resume and539 unchanged originals. Native Linux
|
|
window/input/action/resize evidence is artifacts/debug-window.log; screenshots
|
|
were visually inspected. Both Linux and Windows self-contained packages publish
|
|
successfully. No new Windows/Wine runtime check was run for this addition.
|
|
|
|
Live F2 diagnostics: artifacts/live-debug-full-tests.log passes the full suite
|
|
and539 original hashes. Native SDL live movement/menu/visibility/resize and the
|
|
existing force-control check pass with zero Vulkan errors. Headless lab/VR04/lab
|
|
retains visibility and samples1/2/3 with zero errors; camera/layout/timing groups
|
|
pass. See artifacts/live-debug-window.log and live-debug-return.log. No new
|
|
Windows runtime claim is made.
|
|
Both self-contained platform packages rebuild successfully with this addition.
|
|
|
|
Persistent presentation/widescreen checkpoint: full regression suite passes in
|
|
artifacts/persistent-widescreen-full-tests.log, including539 preserved hashes.
|
|
Native6-load/one-window/one-renderer fullscreen/bounds/focus/pointer checks pass
|
|
with zero enabled-layer errors (artifacts/window-transition-final.log). F1/force
|
|
and F2 input checks still pass. Both packages rebuild; packaged Linux1920x1080
|
|
lab/VR04/lab retains one renderer and exact RETURN state with validation unavailable.
|
|
No new native Windows runtime claim is made.
|
|
|
|
Known visual/behavior limits include incomplete lighting/fog/blend/culling/material
|
|
mapping, inferred model/root pivot, provisional collision/cadence/animation timing,
|
|
close-wall camera clipping near Jimmy, incomplete class-specific triggers/interactions,
|
|
and no original comparison captures. Walk evidence: artifacts/walk-tests.log,
|
|
test-walk.ppm, walk-start.png and walk-window.ppm. Original fidelity is unverified.
|